Obiettivi formativi
The module aims to teach how to:
- demonstrate knowledge of the key institutions/structures, principles and concepts of international trade law and their relevance to international economic relations;
- identify the relevant sources of international trade law and their relationship to domestic legal systems;
- demonstrate a clear understanding and critical appreciation of the legal, economic and political issues involved in structures of global economic governance;
- carry out competent and independent research into some aspects of the law relating to international regulatory institutions;
- critically assess the different approaches to the problems and issues raised and, where appropriate, to critically review the relationship of law to economics in this area.
Risultati di apprendimento attesi
On the completion of the module, students will be expected to:
Subject-specific
- Identify and analyse the subjects, sources, scope and content of substantive international trade law rules.
- Identify and analyse dispute settlement mechanisms in international trade law.
- Identify the overlaps, similarities and differences among divergent legal instruments.
- Explain the role and objectives of international trade law in theory and in practice.
- Describe and demonstrate the relationship between the objectives of liberalization in international trade system on the one hand, and other regulatory interests and objectives on the other.
Skills
- Analyse complex legal principles of international trade law and give advice about their application in practice.
- Evaluate the differences among divergent legal instruments and understand their practical implications.
- Compare and assess the role and objectives of international trade law in theory and in practice.
- Critically reflect on the existence of conflicting regulatory objectives of international trade law and their appropriate balance.
- Present and communicate their research findings effectively.
Attributes
- Acquire knowledge in a rigorous and time-efficient way.
- Use analytical skills to develop solid legal arguments and find solutions to complex legal problems.
- Strengthen legal research skills.
- Learn independently.
Prerequisiti
The module will encourage the development of:
• High-level oral communication skills through reflective, analytical class discussion;
• Advanced critical reading skills in relation to primary and/or secondary sources;
• High-level writing skills through close and critical analysis of both primary and secondary source material;
• An ability to apply theoretical and contextual knowledge to practical problems that face people working in the field.
Contenuti Del Corso
The purpose of this course is to examine the economic interactions between States as well as the economic relationships between States and non-government entities, in particular corporations. It aims to critically assess not only the law governing these relationships but also the different law-making processes. The main goal is to provide an overview of the legal and institutional foundations of international trade law. It covers issues such as multilateral and regional trade law principles/doctrines, investment, sustainable development, and regional economic integration principles. The first section covers GATT/WTO rules, thus analysing the basic principles of the world trading system and offering an analysis of international trade rules governing trade in goods, services, IP rights and their relationship with other regulatory interests (environment, security, social issues); lecturers will also engage with the dispute settlement procedures available for trade disputes between States. The second section covers foreign investments: firstly, it identifies and examines the sources, scope and content of the substantive international law rules that determine investor-State relationships, also by discussing their application in practice. Secondly, it explores the complex system of dispute resolution both from a theoretical and practical perspective, with specific references to investment arbitration. The last section considers the interactions between trade/investment rules with public policy issues, by analysing – through seminars and guest lecturers – the complex relations between international trade law and other branches of international law aimed at protecting general (and global) objectives (environment, climate change, corporate social responsibility). This module is suitable for students interested in acquiring a thorough and deep understanding of international trade and investment law, as well as in critically assessing the role and objectives of this body of law and its balancing against other regulatory interests. It also provides the theoretical and practical knowledge necessary for legal practitioners in the field and for those seeking to advice governmental bodies, private companies or civil society organisations, on matters related to international trade law and policy.
Testi Di Riferimento
F.M. Palombino (eds.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025,
In case the book will not be published, as an alternative please refer to:
Main textbooks
- P. Van Den Bossche, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization. Text, Cases and Materials, 5th edn., Cambridge University Press, 2021 (CHAPTERS 1,2,3,4,5, 10 and 15)
- D. Collins, An Introduction to International Investment Law, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, 2023 (CHAPTERS 1,2,3,4, 5,6,8 and 9)
Metodologie Didattiche
Teaching will combine traditional lectures offered by the lecturers with power point presentations and seminar method, whereby material is prepared in advance and made available online for class discussion. Students are strongly encouraged to attend all classes and to adequately study the recommended material before each lecture. Documents, cases, presentations, and articles will be provided prior of each class.
The teaching on a bi-weekly basis is structured as follows:
WEEK 1 - lecture 1 (on campus) 1h 30’: ACQUISITION
WEEK 1 - lecture 2 (on campus) 1h 30’: ACQUISITION
WEEK 2 - lecture 1 (on campus) 1h 30’: ACQUISITION
WEEK 2 - lecture 2 (on campus) 1h 30’: PARTICIPATION, DISCUSSION – critical discussion of issues, team activities, peer review between students.
Modalità di verifica dell'apprendimento
Continuous assessment + final oral exam
Continuous assessment:
- two midterm written exams (multiple-choice quiz) the first midterm exam will be scheduled after the conclusion of the modules on GATT/WTO law (25% of the final mark); the second midterm exam will be scheduled after the conclusion of the module on foreign investment law (25% of the final mark).
- group presentations to be illustrated in class (including case study analysis, critical review of issues supported by journal articles) will be scheduled during the last section of the course (25% of the final mark).
Final oral exam (25% of the final mark):
- Questions on topics illustrated during the last section of the course (Weeks 8-12) and related to the topics analysed during the first two sections (Weeks 1-7) of the course. The oral performance will be assessed by taking into account the following criteria: (i) identification of relevant issues and evidence of thorough knowledge and understanding of the principles of law; (ii) reasoned arguments and supporting sources; (iii) logical conclusions.
A marking rubric with details for each class of grade will be available on the module webpage.
Criteri per l’assegnazione dell’elaborato finale
The thesis is assigned subject to the submission of a preliminary dissertation proposal under the following criteria:
Content
• Structure your essay: introduction, development and conclusion.
• Use signposts.
• Introductory and concluding paragraphs are crucial.
• Answer what you have been asked and not what you would have liked to be asked.
• Support your argument with evidence: legislation, cases, declarations of international organisations, policy documents, authors’ opinions, facts, etc.
• Do not be afraid of expressing your personal opinion but stay away of sweeping generalisations.
The thesis normally takes up to one year of supervision and will be assigned upon the achievement of the very high performance/grade (minimum 28/30).
Settimana 1
Introduction to International Trade Law
Aims and Objectives
The lectures discuss the general background and main sources of International Trade Law. They cover issues such subjects and sources of this body of law, comparing their roles and application to subjects and rules of public international law
Readings
F.M. Palombino (eds.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 2
Settimana 2
The WTO architecture: GATT Agreement, GATS Agreement and TRIPS Agreement
Aims and Objectives
The aim of the lectures is to discuss the institutions and multilateral treaties regulating International Trade Law - WTO (GATT and GATS) and to understand the underlying principles governing the WTO multilateral trading system. It also examines the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement and other relevant WTO agreements.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economia Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, ch. 4
Alternative
P. Van Den Bossche, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization. Text, Cases and Materials, 5th edn., Cambridge University Press, 2021, Ch. 2, 4, 5 and 15.
Active learning - Discuss the GATS, its basic definitions, obligations, and concepts. Where possible, compare GATS and GATT rules, indicating the similarities and differences between the two agreements.
Settimana 3
The WTO Dispute Settlement System
Aims and Objectives
The lectures aim at understanding the complex system of dispute settlement provided by the WTO Agreement and by the Dispute Settlement Understanding, by identifying the elements of the different phases (amicable settlement; panel/appellate procedures; subsequent remedies) of a dispute. In addition, the lectures propose a scrutiny of the current status of the dispute settlement mechanism and of certain landmark cases dealing with the national security exception.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economia Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, ch. 4
Alternative
P. Van Den Bossche, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization. Text, Cases and Materials, 5th edn., Cambridge University Press, 2021, Ch. 3.
Settimana 4
Regional Trade Agreements, Preferential Trade Agreements and Free Trade Agreements
Aims and Objectives
This lecture provides a critical analysis of Regional Trade Agreements (RTAs), in their different forms, as they have been concluded between two or more States. These agreements have proliferated in recent years: the lecture will deal with their contents, discussing the difference between RTAs and WTO, and the WTO rules on RTAs.
Readings
P. Van Den Bossche, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization. Text, Cases and Materials, 5th edn., Cambridge University Press, 2021, Ch. 10.
Active learning - Given the tremendous proliferation of regional trade agreements in recent years, the WTO is losing its centrality in the international trading system. Would you agree that the above statement is still accurate? Discuss.
Settimana 5
The rules on foreign investments
Aims and Objectives
The lectures focus on the law governing the liberalization of foreign investment. This law developed starting in the 1960s and accelerated after the end of the Cold War: the lectures discuss rules on the liberalization, protection and promotion, facilitation of foreign investment contained in bilateral, regional and mega-regional treaties (IIAs – international investment agreements). Attention will be given the EU common commercial policy and the EU strategies regarding foreign investments.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 3
Alternative
D. Collins, An Introduction to International Investment Law, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, 2023, Ch. 1, 2 and 3.
Settimana 6
Standards of treatment of foreign investments
Aims and Focus
The aim of these classes is to provide a knowledge of the specific rules regarding the treatment of foreign investments under IIAs, with specific attention to Fair and Equitable Treatment and to the rules regarding the prohibition of expropriation, as have been developed in treaties and applied in caselaw.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 3
Alternative
D. Collins, An Introduction to International Investment Law, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, 2023, Ch. 4, 5 and 6.
Active learning - Critically discuss: Under investment law, do host states have obligations? What about corporations?
Settimana 7
Foreign Investment Disputes
Aims and Objectives
These classes focus on the processes through which foreign investment disputes are settled, taking into consideration the switch from the ‘gun-boat’ diplomacy to ISDS proceedings, where foreign investors have the right to bring a dispute against the host state before a private arbitral tribunal constituted to hear that specific case. These lectures will discuss the main aspects of this system, its limits, the backlash currently surrounding investment arbitration and the proposed reform of this system.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 3
Alternative
D. Collins, An Introduction to International Investment Law, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, 2023, Ch. 8.
Settimana 8
Investors’ protection vs. States’ right to regulate
Aims and Objectives
These lectures will deal with the complex balancing between investors’ protection and States’ right to regulate for public objectives (health, environment, climate goals, human and indigenous people rights), analysing caselaw on such matters. Also, the classes will analyse the practice of States’ counterclaims in investment arbitration.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.) Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 3
Alternative
D. Collins, An Introduction to International Investment Law, 2nd edn., Cambridge University Press, 2023, Ch. 9.
Active learning - Discuss the case Rockhopper v. Italy; Urbaser v. Argentina.
Settimana 9
Trade and Environment
Aims and Objectives
This seminar focuses on the much-debated topic of the trade and environment nexus. Trade can be good or bad to the environment, depending on the nature and implications of the trade flows. An important debate is the extent to which WTO agreements leave enough room for environmental considerations.
Readings
- H. van Asselt, ‘Trade’, in L. Rajamani and J. Peel (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of International Environmental Law (OUP, 2021), Chapter 43;
- L. Rajamani and J.D. Werksman, Climate Change, in L. Rajamani and J. Peel (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of International Environmental Law (OUP, 2021) Chapter 29.
Active learning (group presentations): the transition to sustainability requires governmental intervention into the economy. Are trade rules consistent or inconsistent with a transition to sustainability? Critically discuss.
Settimana 10
Trade, Investment, Climate and the Energy Sector: the Energy Charter Treaty
Aims and objectives
The lectures focus on the main specific treaty governing investment, trade and transit in energy in the Pan-European region, namely the Energy Charter Treaty. It covers its aims, structure and the current debate regarding its role in the EU energy transition and the current backlash against this Treaty, as well as the failure of the “modernization” project.
Readings
- J.E. Viñuales, The International Law of Energy (CUP, 2022) pp. 10-41;
- K. Hobér, The Energy Charter Treaty. A Commentary (OUP, 2020) chapter 2, pp. 3-12.
Active learning (group presentations): The EU has become increasingly critical about the role of the Energy Charter Treaty as an obstacle to its transition to a low-carbon energy matrix. Yet, the Energy Charter Treaty was initially an EU creature, developed precisely to secure access to the fossil-fuels of the former soviet bloc. Critically discuss.
Settimana 11
International Financial Law
Aims and Objectives
This seminar focuses on the roles and activities of the International Monetary Fund and of the World Bank Group. Students will learn the functioning of these institutions and their objectives.
Readings
F.M. Palombino (ed.), Introduction to International Economic Law, Routledge-Giappichelli, forthcoming 2025, Ch. 5
Active learning (group presentations)
Critically discuss the complex relationship between international financial law and human rights rules and environmental safeguards.
Settimana 12
Corporate Social Responsibility
Aims and Objectives
The lectures focus on the regulation of the activities of multinational corporations, whose actions have come to scrutiny particularly due to their impact on the environment, human rights and labor rights: these classes discuss the current legal framework dedicated to corporations, including the recent initiatives undertaken by the United Nations and the European Union, together with examples of codes of conduct adopted by companies.
Readings
- P. Muchlinski, Multinational Enterprises & the Law (3rd ed, OUP, 2021) Chapter 3;
- Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Implementing the United Nations “Protect, Respect and Remedy” Framework, UN Doc A/HRC/17/31, 2011
Active Learning (group presentations): Domestic caselaw discussion on CSR.