COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY IN EUROPE
Obiettivi formativi
The course aims at providing the students with a wide knowledge of major public policies pursued at
the EU and national levels. For the different policies, the course will analyse the key institutional
structures and policies pursued, as well as changes in these, comparing across polities and over time. The course will also analyse how different national systems adapt to supranational and international
developments.
Risultati di apprendimento attesi
Knowledge and understanding:
The course will offer key theoretical tools to compare public policies. This course provides advanced
knowledge and analytical resources that will enable students to understand the processes, content
and consequences of different policies across countries, their similarities and differences in the
context of European and international developments.
Applying knowledge and understanding:
The students will be able to:
•apply institutionalist models to cross-national comparative case studies of policy making
such as economic policy, alteration of governance structures and Europeanisation;
•examine major public policies through comparing across countries in Europe as well as
the EU level
•look at how institutions shape, constrain and enable policy making, including policy
change and inertia
Making judgements:
We expect students to be able to analyze public policy and governance models to demonstrate an indepth,
critical understanding of the scope and challenges of public policies.
They are expected to be able to discuss and evaluate key policy initiatives and development in the EU
and its member states.
Throughout the whole course, students will be invited to critically analyse when, how and why certain
policies are pursued.
Communications Skills:
This course will give the students the possibility to acquire and understand major terms and concepts
in order to communicate their ideas, proposals, analysis and critical reasoning in the field of public
policy in the most effective and appropriate way.
Learning skills:
This course will contribute to empower learners giving them the tools to determine why certain public
policies are followed and others are not and to evaluate explanatory the models in an independent
way.
Contenuti Del Corso
The course focuses on the reality of several public policies in several European countries,
offering information about the current discussion in the literature on public policy analysis at different
levels of government (European, national, regional and local) and its mutual relationships and
interactions. It looks at their types, dynamics, external and internal determinants, change and reform,
outcomes and its changing contents in issues like economic, social or environmental policies across
several countries. Major issues will include ‘rationality’ in public policy making, why policies are
changed or persist and the interactions between the EU and national levels of policy making.
Testi Di Riferimento
Dodds, A (2nd ed 2018), Comparative Public Policy (Macmillan)
Schmidt, VA and Thatcher, M (eds) (2013), Resilient Liberalism in Europe’s Political Economy
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Most readings are available via LUISS on-line subscriptions. Other articles and papers in the
syllabus will be uploaded on the course’s web page. For the full reading list, please see LuissLearn
Metodologie Didattiche
Lectures and presentations on relevant empirical issues. Students’ participation during lectures is
strongly encouraged and will be considered in the final assessment.
Modalità di verifica dell'apprendimento
The main exam is composed of six questions of an unseen exam, at the end of the course covering
the whole course programme.
Students attending the course (students who have participated and made the presentation) can take
three exam questions that count for 75% and participation counts for 25%.
Students not attending the course will have to answer 4 exam questions.
Students who want to participate in class presentations must sign up for them in the first weeks of
the course. Presentations can be done by one to four students in each class. Presentations assigned
on the basis of one class topic will be presented to the class at the following class (e.g. the group task
assigned in session 7 is to be presented at the beginning of session 8).
Criteri per l’assegnazione dell’elaborato finale
28 or higher in this course and others; suitable topic and clear research question
Il syllabus affronta temi collegati alla sostenibilità?
Not directly but links with regulation of energy
Settimana 1
Introduction to the course and key concepts Different approaches to comparative public policy
Settimana 2
Debate: Can the spread of neo-liberalism be explained just by the personal interests of politicians and large firms? 1 group for and 1 against
Topic of lectures and debates: What is neo-liberalism and how does it differ from social democracy
Key readings:
Schmidt, VA and Thatcher, M (eds) (2013), Resilient Liberalism in Europe’s Political Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)- chs 1 and 14
Jessop, B (2014): A specter is haunting Europe: a neoliberal phantasmagoria, Critical Policy Studies, DOI: 10.1080/19460171.2014.944368
Dodds, A (2nd ed 2018), Comparative Public Policy (Macmillan), ch 8
Further reading
Crouch, C (2011), The Strange Non-Death of Neo-liberalism (Cambridge: Polity) ch 1
For brief discussions of key concepts, Matthew Eagleton-Pierce Neoliberalism: The Key Concepts, Routledge 2016
Settimana 3
Student presentation of one reason for the resilience of neo-liberal ideas, comparing two countries, and then discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debate: State ownership, privatization and the spread of liberal institutions
Debate: Has the spread of privatization in Europe been driven mainly by ideas? (one group for, and 2nd against)
Settimana 4
Student presentation: privatization in one sector comparing two countries, and then discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debate: The regulatory state
Debate: the regulatory state model is dominant in Europe today
Settimana 5
Student presentation: taking one aspect of Majone’s ‘regulatory state’ and critically examine to what extent it has developed in two polities (ie countries in European or one country and the EU) , followed by discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debates: Delegation to non-majoritarian institutions and Independent Regulatory Agencies (IRAs)
Debate: rational calculating politicians create IRAs
Settimana 6
Student presentation comparing the creation of one major Independent regulatory authority in two countries, followed by discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and discussion: Varieties of capitalism
Debate: can countries maintain different varieties of capitalism in the face of globalisation? 1 group for and one against
Settimana 7
student presentation looking at the extent to which ONE polity fits the VoC typology, followed by discussion and debate
Lecture- The spread of independent central banks
No debate
Settimana 8
student presentation comparing the creation of two ICBs in different polities followed by discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debate: Industrial Policy
Debate: Have European states lost the ability to undertake industrial policies? 1 group for and 1 against
Settimana 9
Student presentation: compare public policies towards promoting former national champion in the same sector in 2 major European countries, followed by discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debate: Network industries and internationalization
Debate: liberalization and privatisation have not stopped governments supporting former monopolists in network industries
Settimana 10
Student presentation: compare policies towards aiding two major former monopolists to internationalize in the same network sector in two different countries, followed by discussion and debate
Topic of lectures and debate Cultural Heritage policies in Europe
Settimana 11
Student presentation: Compare the development of legislation to protect historic buildings after 1945 in two European countries
Lecture- reconsideration of neo-liberalism
Settimana 12
-