COMPARATIVE HISTORY OF POLITICAL SYSTEMS
Intended learning outcomes
By the end of this course students will be able to:
Identify key individuals, events, and turning points in European, international, and global history since World War I
Identify and use some of the key perspectives on, and theories about democracy, totalitarianism, and revolution
Analyze a variety of arguments about the causes of the rise, consolidation, and crisis of democracies in and outside Europe after World War I
Develop and present their own arguments about the causes and consequences of key political processes in twentieth century European, international, and global history
Connect historical events and processes to current debate on the state and prospect of democracy
Course Contents
This course examines the historical development of democracy, authoritarianism, and revolution in and outside Europe from World War I to the present day. It uses a series of historical events and processes as a foundation upon which to build a broader understanding of how political orders and systems emerge, function, and are consolidated over time.
We will first consider concepts and theories on democratization, totalitarianism, and revolution. We will then deal with a series of empirical cases, including the totalitarian regimes in interwar Europe (Italian Fascism, German Nazism, and Soviet Bolshevism), the political transformation of Europe in the wake of Word War II (with a specific focus of Italy and Germany), the revolutionary experience of China in the 1940s, the changing face of France from the Fourth to the Fifth Republic (late 1950s), the transition to democracy in Southern and Eastern Europe (respectively in the 1970s and in late 1980s), the Iranian Revolution of 1979, and the hopes for democratic change that swept across the Middle East and North Africa at the time of the Arab Spring (2011).
Along the way, we will explore crucial issues that intersect with the question of the political, such as religion, memory, gender, political identity, class, and race.
By the end of the course, students will be able to problematize democracy as a historical and political concept in the twentieth century, as well as the processes by which democracy has come to be known as the ‘norm’ on the political stage. Students will also develop their ability to think historically and place geographically diverse developments into a singular, global analytical plane. They will, finally, learn to craft and defend historical arguments, to put contemporary concepts in historical perspective, and to read primary sources analytically.
Reference Books
See the (provisional) weekly reading list below
A full and more detailed list of readings (including books, articles, documentaries, films, and other sources) will be distributed on the first day of class
All readings will be accessible on Moodle
Teaching Methods
This course works as a discussion seminar, and as an active workshop. Its success depends on you. Please come to class having done the readings and ready to engage with your peers. Don’t be shy and speak your mind. There is no ‘class point of view’ nor are there ‘preferred answers’. I believe the most interesting and engaging classes are those where people present a diversity of opinions. I actively strive to make classes open spaces of encounters and exchanges of ideas, critiques, and experiences.
Assessment Method
Class participation (discussion, response to discussion questions, case studies, teamwork)
(Short) written assignments
Book review
Final research paper/creative work (the topic must be original (no re-hash of class discussion!)
Thesis assignment criteria
Active participation in class discussion
The topic must be original
Does the syllabus cover sustainability topics?
no
Week 1 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Introduction
Session I (online): Presentation of the course & getting to know you
Session II (campus): Democracy and the Empty Place of Power
Hannah Arendt, ‘What is Authority’, in Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought (New York: Viking Press, 1968), 91-141
Claude Lefort, ‘The Question of Democracy’, in Democracy and Political Theory (Minneapolis, Minn.: University of Minnesota Press, 1988), 9-20
Week 2 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Concepts, Theories, Methodologies
Session I (online): Democracy and Liminality
Session II (campus): The Anthropology of Political Revolution
Harald Wydra, ‘Liminality and Democracy’, in Agnes Horvath, Bjørn Thomassen, and Harald Wydra (eds.), Breaking Boundaries: Varieties of Liminality (New York and Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2018), 183-204
Bjørn Thomassen, ‘Notes Towards an Anthropology of Political Revolution’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 54/2 (2012): 679-706
Week 3 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Totalitarianism in Interwar Europe
Session I (online) – Transgression and Transcendence
Session II (campus) –Trickster Makes the World
Simonetta Falaschi-Zamponi, Fascist Spectacle: The Aesthetic of Power in Mussolini’s Italy (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2000), pp. 43-88
Marcel Mauss, ‘A Sociological Asssment of Bolshevism’ (1924-1925), Economy and Society 13/3 (1984): 331-374
Robert Conquest, The Great Terror: A Reassessment (40th Anniversary Edition) (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), excerpts
Week 4 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
In the Wake of World War II
Session I (online) – The Problem of Democracy in Postwar Europe
Session II (campus) – On the Edge of Democracy: Italy and Germany
Martin Conway, ‘Democracy in Postwar Western Europe: The Triumph of a Political Model’, European History Quarterly 32/1 (2002): 59-84
Rosario Forlenza, On the Edge of Democracy: Italy, 1943-148 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019), excerpts
Elizabeth Heineman, ‘The Hour of the Women: Memories of German’s Crisis Year and West German National Identity’, The American Historical Review 101/2(1996): 354-395
Week 5 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Revolution in China
Session I (online) – Revolution, New Democracy, and Making of the New China
Session II (campus) – ‘Revolution Is Not a Dinner Party’
Lucien Bianco, Stalin & Mao: A Comparison of the Russian and Chinese Revolution (Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press, 2018), excerpts
Alexander C. Cook, ‘Mao’s Little Red Book: The Spiritual Atom Bomb and Its Global Fallout’, in Keith Michael Baker and Dan Edelstein (eds.), Scripting Revolution: A Historical Approach to the Comparative Study of Revolutions (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2016), 251-266
Week 6 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
The French Fifth Republic
Session I (online) – Gaullist Democracy
Session II (campus) – Decolonization, Revolution, and Democracy
Nicholas Atkin, The Fifth French Republic (Palgrave Macmillan: Basingstoke, 2005), 1-58
Frantz Fanon, ‘Concerning Violence’, in The Wretched of the Earth (New York: Grove Press, 1966), 34-105
Week 7 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Democracy in Southern Europe
Session I (online) – The New Spain
Session II (campus) – Memory, Justice and Democracy
Laura Desfor Edles, Symbols and Rituals in the New Spain: The Transition to Democracy after Franco (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 3-10, 11-25, 41-62, 139-150
Carolyn P. Boyd, ‘The Politics of History and Memory in Democratic Spain’, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 617(2008): 133-148
Week 8 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
The Iranian Revolution
Session I (online) – Shi’ism and Revolution
Session II (campus) – Revolt as a Political Spirituality
Nikki R. Keddie, ‘Iranian Revolutions in Comparative Perspective’, The American Historical Review 88/3 (1983): 579-588
Said Amir Arjomand, ‘Iran’s Islamic Revolution in Comparative Perspective’, World Politics 38/3 (1986): 383-414
Michel Foucault, ‘Political Spirituality as a Will for Alterity: An Interview with the Nouvel Observateur’, Critical Inquiry 47/1 (2020): 121-134
Week 9 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Democratic Transformation in Central and Eastern Europe
Session I (online) – 1989: The end of history?
Session II (campus) – Ostalgie, or How to Idealize the GDR
Vladimir Tismaneanu, ‘The Revolutions of 1989: Causes, Meanings, Consequences’, Contemporary European History 18/3 (2009): 271-288
Padraic Kenney, A Carnival of Revolution: Central Europe, 1989 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2003), 157-191
Film: Goodbye Lenin! (2003), director: Wolfgang Becker
Week 10 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
The Arab Spring
Session I (online) – Understanding the Revolutions of 2011
Session II (campus) – Democracy and Square Movements
Jack A. Goldstone, ‘Understanding the Revolutions of 2011: Weakness and Resilience in Middle Eastern Autocracies’,
Foreign Affairs 90/3 (2011): 8-16
Walter Armbrust, ‘The Trickster in Egypt’s January 25 Revolution’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 55/4 (2013): 834-864
Documentary: The Square (2013), director: Jehane Noujaim
Week 11 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Challenges to Democracy in the Twenty-First Century
Session I (online) – Debate on Democracy, Inequality, and Populism,
Session II (campus) – Debate on Democracy after the Coronavirus
Week 12 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Conclusion
Session I (online): recap and final discussion
Session II (campus): recap and final discussion