CORPORATE TRANSACTIONS AND BUSINESS VALUATION

Eugenio Pinto

Instructional goals

The course provides a theoretical and operational framework for business valuation processes and for the main corporate transactions, aiming to make students able not only to understand them, but to perform them. The path starts from business valuation — information base, income and cash-flow based methods, cost of capital, market-based methods — and uses the tools thus acquired to address corporate transactions, where value estimation is the technical prerequisite of the exchange ratio, of the contribution appraisal and of price determination. Alongside the doctrinal framework, the course devotes attention to professional practice: the deal process and the role of advisors, due diligence, contractual price mechanisms, the financial structure of the transaction and the critical reading of valuation reports. The final objective is to promote a critical approach to the use of methods, in relation to the specific purposes pursued and their particular characteristics.

Prerequisites

The course postulates prior knowledge of the basic concepts of Corporate Finance, Financial Mathematics and Business Administration, with particular reference to financial statement analysis. Basic working familiarity with spreadsheets is required. An optional levelling session is made available at the beginning of the course for students who request it.

Intended learning outcomes

Knowledge and understanding: the student will acquire the basic knowledge, both theoretical and operational, concerning business valuation and the implementation of corporate transactions by companies, as well as the professional process within which these activities take place. Applying knowledge and understanding: the student will be able to build a complete business valuation starting from a real information base — normalisation of results, cash-flow forecasting, cost of capital estimation, application of market-based methods — and to design a corporate transaction by determining its economic parameters. These skills are assessed through weekly applied labs, case study analysis, the continuous assessment tests and the applied section of the final written test. Making judgements: the student will be encouraged to develop a critical awareness allowing the formulation of independent judgments on the feasibility of a corporate transaction, on the results achieved through the application of valuation methods, and on the reliability of a valuation report drawn up by third parties. To this end the course includes structured adversarial discussion activities on real valuation documents. Communication skills: the student may gain the ability to describe and argue the salient aspects of a corporate transaction and of a valuation process, both in writing and through the oral presentation and defence of their own work before a critical audience. Learning skills: the student may be able to grasp what is addressed in case study analysis and in the applied labs, and to transfer it autonomously to new circumstances.

Course Contents

Capital configurations and the different business valuation methods: information base and fundamental analysis, income and cash-flow based methods, cost of capital, market-based methods, critical reading of valuation reports. The economic and financial aspects of the main corporate transactions: acquisition and disposal, contribution in kind, conversion, merger and demerger. As regards corporate transactions, the course analyses the economic-corporate function of the main operations, with an indication of accounting and legal effects, and considers their professional execution process, the contractual price mechanisms and the financial structure, including the leveraged buy-out.

Reference Books

For Business Valuation: • Bini, Guatri (2007), La valutazione delle aziende, Egea • Corbella, Liberatore, Tiscini (2020), Manuale di valutazione d'azienda, McGraw-Hill • Pinto E., Di taluni aspetti della valutazione del capitale economico delle aziende, Giuffrè, and chapter 62 of the Liber Amicorum referred to in the week 3 programme (chapters provided as handouts) • Organismo Italiano di Valutazione, Italian Valuation Standards (PIV), current edition For Corporate Transactions: • Teaching material provided by the lecturer and/or textbook in preparation Supplementary materials available on the course platform: weekly pre-work sheets, dossier of the company used for the yearly project, real valuation reports and corporate documents, spreadsheet templates.

Teaching Methods

The course adopts a flipped classroom approach. Descriptive coverage is assigned to pre-work material — slides, readings and weekly sheets — which students address before class; class time is devoted to application, discussion and correction. Each week consists of two ninety-minute classes with distinct functions. The first includes an initial check on the pre-work through closed-answer questions with aggregated results, a dialogic lecture on conceptual issues and points of doctrinal divergence, and the briefing of the lab task with its constraints. The second includes the team-based applied lab producing a defined artefact, which stays with the team and is not handed in, the plenary discussion of results comparing divergent solutions, the connection with the yearly project and with a recently announced market transaction, and in the final ten minutes the individual continuous-assessment test. No deliverable produced outside class is handed in or graded. The valuation model of the yearly project stays with the team for the whole semester: its return is the in-class discussion and Part B of the final written test, which is set on the same company's data. The course also includes: case study analysis and discussion; adversarial analysis of real valuation reports and documents; a term sheet negotiation simulation; an investment committee simulation; the progressive spreadsheet construction of a valuation model of an actual listed company, selected each year; testimonies from experts in advisory, institutional investment and the valuation profession. The use of generative artificial intelligence tools in preparing deliverables is permitted and must be declared in a dedicated appendix, indicating the tools used and the steps involved. The safeguard is not prohibition but the structure of assessment: two thirds of the mark are determined in an in-person written test, without devices. Continuous assessment tests are delivered in class, in the final ten minutes of the second weekly session, on the platform and with random item selection from question banks, individual numerical variants and tight time limits.

Assessment Method

The final mark is expressed out of thirty and consists of two parts: continuous assessment, weighing one third, and the final written verbalising test, weighing two thirds. Both parts are measured on a 0 to 33 point scale. Distinction (lode) is awarded above 31.5. Continuous assessment applies only to students who have attended at least 70% of class sessions, and only in the first examination session following the end of the course: students below that attendance threshold, and all students sitting the exam in later sessions, have their mark determined entirely by the written test. 1) Written exam only: this type of exam consists exclusively of a written test and does not include an oral exam. The test comprises a section of closed-answer questions, a section of quantitative exercises on valuation and corporate transactions and a section of critical analysis of a valuation document, identifying the methods used and the debatable parameters. Two versions exist, depending on the attendance to the course. The marks are published on the specified website and the student receives notification of the result of the written exam, which will also be visible on the self-service website. It’s not possible to refuse the mark. 2) Continuous assessment, worth 33 points, consists of a single component: ten individual tests delivered in class, in the final ten minutes of the second weekly session, from week two to week eleven. The best eight of the ten count towards the mark: the continuous-assessment score equals 33 points multiplied by the average percentage of correct answers across those eight administrations. Each test draws six items from a weekly pool of twelve, organised in three subcategories — two numerical items with individual variants, two on the lab just completed, two on the week's pre-work — with a ten-minute limit, a single attempt and sequential navigation. The tests are entirely automatically marked. The applied lab artefacts are not handed in and do not contribute to the mark.

Thesis assignment criteria

The request must be submitted at least 6 months before the estimated degree session.

Week 1

Introduction to the course. The market for corporate transactions: players, roles and deal life cycle. Overview and summary table of the main corporate transactions and unified reading scheme: object of the transfer, consideration, effects on ownership structure and on financial statements. Presentation of the company used for the yearly project. Lab: guided reconstruction of actual completed transactions (rationale, structure, price, multiple, outcome).

Week 2

The information base and fundamental analysis. Information sources and databases. Normalisation of results. Strategic analysis. Analysis of the sustainability and reliability of business plans. Asset analysis. Determination of net financial position and capital needs. Chapters 3, 4 and 5 Bini-Guatri. Lab: identification of accounting red flags in the yearly project company; construction of normalised earnings and net financial position.

Week 3

The areas of corporate value measurement. The characteristics of valuations. The notion of economic capital. Values and prices of company capital. Characteristics of methods based on expected returns. The income method: equity side and asset side formulas, economic value and potential value of capital. The asset method. The mixed asset-income model, including with independent estimate of goodwill. Chapters 1, 10, 11 and 12 Bini-Guatri; chapter 62 Liber Amicorum Pinto. Lab: application of the income, asset and mixed methods to a real case; structured discussion on the distinction between value and price.

Week 4

Indirect valuation methods: levered and unlevered cash flows. The Discounted Cash Flow Method. Asset side and equity side valuations and the consistency between flow and rate. The key role of cash-flow forecasting: prospective income statement items, working capital and capital expenditure analysis. The forecast time horizon. The terminal value: steady-state flow, perpetual growth rate, reinvestment rate. Chapters 11 and 12 Bini-Guatri; chapter 2 Pinto; chapter 7 Manuale di valutazione d'azienda. Lab: construction of the discounted cash-flow model of the yearly project company starting from its business plan.

Week 5

The discount rate. The cost of equity: the Capital Asset Pricing Model, the risk-free rate, the market risk premium, unlevered and relevered beta, country risk and size premiums. The cost of debt and the target financial structure. The weighted average cost of capital. The treatment of the cost of capital in valuation reports and in professional practice. Teaching material provided by the lecturer; Manuale di valutazione d'azienda. Lab: independent estimation and reasoned defence of the cost of capital; sensitivity analysis of value to rate and growth.

Week 6

Direct valuation methods. The theory of multiples: true and false multiples, true and false comparables. Equity side and asset side multiples. Multiples of comparable companies: selection of the sample, of the multipliers and of the data, adjustments and final choices. Multiples of comparable transactions. Control premium, minority discount and illiquidity discount. Chapters 13 and 14 Bini-Guatri. Lab: construction of the comparable sample, application of multiples and comparison of results with those of expected-return methods. With this week's exit ticket, continuous assessment reaches its midpoint: five of the ten administrations.

Week 7

The valuation report and the expert's opinion: structure, content and purpose. The expert's report under art. 2501-sexies of the Italian Civil Code and the appraisal under arts. 2343 and 2465. The purposes of valuation and the Italian Valuation Standards as a reference framework. Control methods, sensitivity analysis and the expert's liability. Lab: adversarial analysis of an independent expert's report on an actually executed transaction, with formulation of objections, rebuttals and a reasoned judgment.

Week 8

Acquisition and disposal of a business or business branch: description of the transaction and its economic-corporate function. General scheme. Horizontal, vertical and conglomerate acquisitions; purposes and critical issues. Economic and accounting aspects of the disposal: capital gain and goodwill. Introduction to IFRS 3 – Business Combinations and purchase price allocation. General principles under Italian law. The transaction process: sell side and buy side mandates, information memorandum, due diligence. Contractual price mechanisms: locked box, completion accounts, working capital adjustment, deferred and contingent consideration. Lab: negotiation simulation on a term sheet between buy side and sell side.

Week 9

Contribution of a business or business branch in kind: description of the transaction and its economic-corporate function. General scheme: total or partial contribution to a newly incorporated or existing company. The appraisal under arts. 2343 and 2465 of the Italian Civil Code. Contribution as a tool for group reorganisation and business combination. Conversion: description of the transaction and its economic-corporate function. General scheme. General principles. Homogeneous and heterogeneous conversion. The right of withdrawal. Lab: case study on an actually implemented corporate reorganisation under regulatory constraints, with independent formulation of the solution.

Week 10

The merger: description of the transaction and its economic-corporate function. General scheme. Types of merger: by incorporation and by union. Economic aspects of the merger: surplus and deficit, arising from exchange and from cancellation. Backdating of effects. The exchange ratio as the outcome of the comparison between two valuations: determination criteria, control methods and fairness range. Merger following a leveraged acquisition under art. 2501-bis of the Italian Civil Code; the leveraged and management buy-out. Lab: independent determination of the exchange ratio of an actually approved transaction and comparison with the effective ratio; analysis of the effects on the acquiring company's earnings per share.

Week 11

The demerger: description of the transaction, civil law and economic-accounting aspects. General scheme. Types of demerger: partial and total, proportional and non-proportional, in favour of one or more newly incorporated or existing beneficiary companies. Proportionality and non-proportionality conditions. Economic aspects: demerger differences. The demerger as a tool for separating activities and for divestment. The financial structure of leveraged transactions: sources and uses, debt repayment schedule, investor return measures. Lab: construction of a simplified leveraged acquisition model and discussion of assumptions before a simulated investment committee.

Week 12

Integration: from value to structure. Stand-alone value and value to the acquirer, synergies, control premium and the division of value between the parties; review of the outputs produced in the labs from week four to week eleven. In the second class, reasoned feedback on the ten exit tickets, reopening in class the items the class most often got wrong. Simulation of the final written test, under real examination conditions and timing, on its three parts. In the second class, commented feedback on the simulation, a concluding recap of the whole course and closing session.