CORPORATE LAW & RISK MANAGEMENT
Obiettivi formativi
The course focuses on the law of corporations and risk management. While we will focus primarily on corporations, we will also cover agency and partnership to examine similarities and differences in organizational law. Specific topics will include fiduciary law, shareholder voting, executive compensation, mergers and acquisitions, and corporate governance and risk management. Special emphasis throughout the course will be given to the functional analysis of legal rules and the law and economics method.
Risultati di apprendimento attesi
At the completion of the course, the student will be able to:
Knowledge and understanding
Describe the fundamental rules that govern the employer-employee relationship.
Explore the different types of M&A transactions and agreements
Identify the characteristics of corporations
Applying knowledge and understanding
Apply the basic principles of agency law.
Analyze the distribution of powers within the corporate structure
Analyze the importance of the agency relationships and agency costs that exist within the corporate form
Making Judgements
Evaluate critically legal, economic and political issues involved in corporations
Evaluate relationships and conflicts within the corporate form
Communication Skills
Discuss the characteristics of law of agency and law of partnership
Discuss major issues of corporate governance and risk management, mergers and acquisitions
Learning Skills
Explore dimensions of corporate law and corporate governance including issues of CSR and ESG
Contenuti Del Corso
Agency
Partnership
Introduction to Corporations
Limited Liability and Creditor Protection
The Board of Directors
Shareholder Protection and Voting
Duty of Care
Duty of Loyalty
Introduction to M&A
M&A Law
Executive Compensation
CSR & ESG
Testi Di Riferimento
There are no key textbooks for the course but articles and excepts from books as indicated in the detail below.
Metodologie Didattiche
Teaching Methods
Mix asynchronous (Professor) and synchronous (Teaching Assistants) lectures
Teaching Assistants' office hours
Individual activities to test and assess the level of understanding, through quizzes
Case studies
Podcasts
Modalità di verifica dell'apprendimento
Assessment Methods
Students will be evaluated on the following activities:
Quizzes (60%)
You will have 6 quizzes in this course (each 10% of your final grade). Each quiz will assess your knowledge of the latest two modules. The allocation of modules to be assessed within each quiz is provided below.
Quiz 1: Modules 1 & 2
Quiz 2: Modules 3 & 4
Quiz 3: Modules 5 & 6
Quiz 4: Modules 7 & 8
Quiz 5: Modules 9 & 10
Quiz 6: Modules 11 & 12
Final Evaluation (30%)
You will have one cumulative exam assessing your knowledge throughout the course. This will be a written exam to be carried out online and is your final assignment.
In-person Evaluation (10%)
The final ten percent of your grade will be determined through an in-person evaluation during the exam session. Further details will be released closer to the date.
Criteri per l’assegnazione dell’elaborato finale
None
Il syllabus affronta temi collegati alla sostenibilità?
Yes
Settimana 1
Week 1- Agency
Asynchonous lesson
Overview of the course
Methodological approach
Agency theory
Agency formation
Authority in agency
Agency in torts
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Related Material
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Robert Sitkoff, The Economic Structure of Fiduciary Law, 91 B.U. L. Rev. 1039 (2011) (Sitkoff_2011), 1040-5.
Cases:
Case 1: Jenson Farms Co. v. Cargill, Inc. (legal case)
Case 2: White v. Thomas (legal case)
Case 3: Humble Oil & Refining Co. v. Martin (legal case)
Additional Materials (30 mn. total):
"The Law of Agency," UVA Law Vice Dean George GeisLinks to an external site.
3 components are needed to form agency relationship (@ 2:20)
Examples using HBO's Entourage, a realtor, and a famous CEO
Hypotheticals involving a watch - selling, giving, consignment transaction (@ 16:58)
General framework for agency law (@ 20:31-22:31)
Business Law: The Principal-Agent RelationshipLinks to an external site. – (7 minute video)
Nice overview of the topic covering: Types of Authority; Duties of Principals and Agents; Principal’s Liability for Agent’s Action in Contract and Tort; and Compensation Agents
"Why Textbook Prices Keep Climbing"Links to an external site. - (13 minute podcast)
start @ 2:26
Unique way of explaining principle-agency problems using college textbooks
Settimana 2
Week 2 – Partnership
Asynchonous lesson
Joint ownership
Partnership formation
Creditors’ rights
Termination of partnership
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Related Material
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: George Cohen, The Law and Economics of Agency and Partnership, at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3208640Links to an external site. (17-23)
Reading 3: Philip Thurston, When Partners Fall Out, at https://hbr.org/1986/11/when-partners-fall-outLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Meinhard v. Salmon (legal case)
Case 2: Vohland v. Sweet (legal case)
Additional Material (about 30 mn. total):
Meinhard v. Salmon Case Brief SummaryLinks to an external site.– (2.5 minute video)
The Best Structure for a PartnershipLinks to an external site.– (4 minute video)
What is a Partnership? How One works & What it Can Look LikeLinks to an external site. – (7 minute read)
Covers limited partnership, provides examples, advantages and disadvantages of LP, GP vs LP, LP vs LLC, and LP vs LLP.
Nice graphics mid-read and provides 3 examples of LP including filmmaking, real estate and natural resource exploration.
FIDUCIARY OR FOE? REVISITING MEINHARD V. SALMONLinks to an external site. – (7 minute read)
Content includes: 1) Salmon Meets Meinhard; 2) How Things Went Downhill; 3) Who Won, And Why; and 4) The Aftermath
How to Keep a Partnership StrongLinks to an external site. - (5-7 min read)
WSJ (2017)
Business Negotiation Skills: How to Deal with a Failing Business PartnershipLinks to an external site. – (10 min read)
Harvard Law School – Program on Negotiation
Uses Philadelphia Inquirer as an example of a failing partnership
Discusses a business “prenup,” deadlock during business negotiations, the Texas Shoot-out, and dissolving a partnership through an action
Settimana 3
Week 3 - Introduction to Corporations
Asynchonous lesson:
Corporate form
The function of corporation
Characteristics of corporate form
Corporation as a citizen
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Armour et al., What is Corporate Law?, available at https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198739630.001.0001/acprof-9780198739630-chapter-1Links to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (legal case)
Case 2: Automatic Self-Cleansing Filter Syndicate Co., Ltd. v. Cunninghame (legal case)
Additional Material (60+ mn.):
The Corporation’s PurposeLinks to an external site.– (3.5 minute video)
UC Berkeley Law (2019)
Provides background on history of the corporation and its purpose
Stop at 3:30
Who Do Corporations Really Work For?Links to an external site.– (13 minute video)
Tedx Talks
From printing money to creating community country clubs, corporations have historically provided many services to local societies and workers. But today, corporations often serve shareholders above all. In this talk, Marketplace correspondent Scott Tong chronicles the changing relationship between corporations and society.
Corp 101: The Basics of Corporate StructureLinks to an external site. - (3 minute video)
Business Roundtable (2010)
Business Roundtable's Purpose of a Corporation: One Year LaterLinks to an external site.– (4.5 minute video)
General overview of impact since statement release
Shareholders vs. StakeholdersLinks to an external site. – (36 minute podcast)
Capitalisn’t Podcast (2019)
Discussion of Business Roundtable suggesting that corporations should serve both stakeholders and shareholders
Covers shareholder primacy theory, stakeholders + shareholders ideology, the purpose of the corporation, and the Business Roundtable’s potential underlying motivation
What is CentralizationLinks to an external site. - (Short article < 5 minute read)
Corporate Finance Institute
Overview discussing advantages and disadvantages of centralization
If Corporations Are People, They Should Act Like ItLinks to an external site. (10 minute read)
The Atlantic (2015)
Settimana 4
Week 4 - Limited Liability and Creditor Protection
Asynchonous lesson:
Limited liability
Capital structure
Distribution constraints
Capital regulation
Piercing the corporate veil
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Easterbrook and Fischel, Limited Liability and the Corporation, available at https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4386&context=uclrevLinks to an external site.
Reading 3: Williamson, Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance, available at https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1988.tb04592.xLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Sea-Land Services, Inc. v. The Pepper Source (legal case)
Case 2: Walkovszky v. Carlton (legal case)
Additional Material (about 60 mn.):
Corporate & Commercial: Shareholder LiabilityLinks to an external site.
(5.5 minute video)
The Law of Corporate Debt: A Unifying TheoryLinks to an external site.
(36 minute video)
Richard Squire (Fordham) and Felix Steffek (Cambridge)
Walkovszky v. Carlton Case Brief Summary | Law Case ExplainedLinks to an external site.
(1.5 minute video)
“What it means to buy a company’s stock”Links to an external site. (~ 13 minute video)
Balance sheet basics
Piercing the Corporate VeilLinks to an external site. – (13 minute podcast)
Explains concept of the corporate veil, and then illustrates concept through hypothetical from the bar exam in 2017
Capital Structure – Gearing and Why Debt Finance is CheaperLinks to an external site. – (8 minute podcast)
Essentials of Corporate Financial Management
Capital Structure – financial distressLinks to an external site. - (5 minute podcast)
Essentials of Corporate Financial Management
Settimana 5
Week 5 - The Board of Directors
Asynchonous lesson:
The organization of the board
Executive and independent directors
Electing and removing directors
Board structure and firm performance
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Wommack, The Board’s Most Important Function, available at https://hbr.org/1979/09/the-boards-most-important-functionLinks to an external site.
Reading 3: Cremers and Sepe, The shareholder Value of Empowered Boards, available at https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/print/article/the-shareholder-value-of-empowered-boards/Links to an external site.
Case:
Case 1: How to fire a CEO (hypothetical case)
Additional Material (about 40 mn):
What's Behind Board Member SalariesLinks to an external site. - (6 minute podcast)
WSJ Podcast (2021)
Start @ 6:09; End @ 11:55
Are Corporate Boards Heeding Pressure to Diversify?Links to an external site. - (6 minute podcast)
WSJ - 2021
Start @ 4:41; End @ 10:30
Top Boards Do These 4 Things DifferentlyLinks to an external site. - (5 minute read)
Harvard Business Review (2020)
Review of actions taken by "Gold Medal Boards" and what makes them so successful
Board Effectiveness and the Chair of the FutureLinks to an external site. - (5-7 minute read)
Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance (2022)
Survey of more than 300 board chairs in 16 countries to identify 5 fundamental areas of change
Back to Basics: Board CommitteesLinks to an external site. – (10 minute read)
HLS Forum on Corporate Governance (2022)
Good info on current state of board committee structures
What is Dodd-Frank? Links to an external site.
(4:30 minute video)
CNBC Video Summary of the act and update since the law’s creation
Settimana 6
Week 6 - Shareholder Protection and Voting
Asynchonous lesson:
Exit, voice, and loyalty
Control rights and cash flow rights
Proxy solicitation and reimbursement
Controlling minority structure
Voting and judicial monitoring
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Armour et al., The Basic Governance Structure: The Interest of Shareholders as a Class, available at https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198739630.001.0001/acprof-9780198739630-chapter-3Links to an external site.
Reading 3: Easterbrook and Fischel, Voting in Corporate Law, available at https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/467043Links to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Rosenfeld v. Fairchild Engine & Airplane Corp. (legal case)
Case 2: Schnell v. Chris-Craft Industries, Inc. (legal case)
Additional Material (60+ mn.):
What is Proxy Voting?Links to an external site.– (3 minute video)
A primer on Proxy VotingLinks to an external site. – (12 minute video)
Morningstar (2020)
Stockholder’s RightsLinks to an external site. – (18 minute video)
Covers the following: 1) Right to Vote; 2) Right to Receive Dividends; 3) Right to Sell Shares; 4) Right to Share in Company Assets Upon Dissolution; 5) Right to Inspect Company Records; and 6) Litigation Rights
Money Talks’ Proxy WarsLinks to an external site. – (26 minute podcast)
Starts @ 1:46
Annual meetings and why the number of shareholder proposals has increased in recent years
Helping a Client Exercise His Shareholder RightsLinks to an external site. - (5 minute read)
WSJ – 2014
Settimana 7
Week 7 - Duty of Care
Asynchonous lesson:
Introduction to corporate fiduciary duties
Duty of care: function
The business judgement rule
Duty to be informed and competent
Risk management: duty to monitor
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Riley, The Company Director's Duty of Care and Skill: The Case for an Onerous but Subjective Standard, available at https://www.jstor.org/stable/1097382#metadata_info_tab_contentsLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Kamin v. American Express Co. (legal case)
Case 2: Graham v. Allis-Chalmers Manufacturing Co. (legal case)
Case 3: In re Caremark International Inc. (legal case)
Additional Material (about 60 mn.):
Fiduciary Duties of Corporate Officers and DirectorsLinks to an external site. - (4 minute podcast)
The Business Judgement Rule and the Fiduciary Duty ofLinks to an external site. Care – (5 minute video)
General overview
Graham v. Allis-Chalmers Manufacturing Co. Case BriefLinks to an external site.– (3 minute video
Bad Bets - Enron, Ep2: The VisionaryLinks to an external site. – (34 minute podcast)
WSJ Podcast
Director’s and Officers’ Duty of Care – Pay Attention and Take Responsibility!Links to an external site. – (10 minute read)
Covers the basics of fiduciary duties and a detailed discussion regarding multiple components related to the duty of care
Settimana 8
Week 8 - Duty of Loyalty
Asynchonous lesson:
Duty to whom?
Conflict of interest
Disclosure and ratification
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Baird and Henderson, Others People’s Money, available at http://www.stanfordlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2010/04/BairdHenderson.pdfLinks to an external site.
Reading 3: Bratton, The "Nexus of Contracts" Corporation: A Critical Appraisal, available at https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1838&context=faculty_scholarshipLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Dodge v. Ford Motor Company (legal case)
Case 2: Weinberger v. UOP (legal case)
Additional Material (about 30 mn.):
Duty of Loyalty and TakeoversLinks to an external site.– (8 minute video)
When Dodge Bought FordLinks to an external site.– (10 minute video – hardstop at @10 due to language)
Recap of the events between Dodge brothers and Henry Ford from the perspective of a mechanic
Unique and informal, but could be an interesting supplement to the case reading
Conflicts of Interest and a Director’s Duty of LoyaltyLinks to an external site. – (7 minute podcast)
Apple accused of monitoring ex-chip exec text messagesLinks to an external site. – (5 minute read)
Covers Gerard Williams and controversy with his heading to Nuvia (chip start-up)
Settimana 9
Week 9 - Introduction to M&A
Asynchonous lesson:
M&A: economics
Transaction forms
E-tivities
Readings
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: [On the economics of M&A, TBD]
Reading 3: Easterbrook and Fischel, The Proper Role of a Target's Management in Responding to a Tender Offer, available at https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3067&context=journal_articlesLinks to an external site.
Additional Material (60+ mn.):
Three-part video series
Acquisitions and sharesLinks to an external site. (3:46 min)
Price behavior after announced acquisitionLinks to an external site. (4:03 min)
Simple merger arbitrage with share acquisitionLinks to an external site. (4:21 min)
Sold: Victoria’s SecretLinks to an external site. – (17 minute podcast)
WSJ – The Journal (2020)
Focus on CEO Les Wexner and the historical trajectory of Victoria’s Secret
Good example of some causal factors leading to M&A
How a Deal to Buy Tiffany Lost Its Sparkle - First Resource on Tiffany M&ALinks to an external site. – (15 minute podcast) -
WSJ – The Journal (2020)
Reviews the (at the time of this podcast) failed attempt from LVMH to acquire Tiffany & Co
Can Elon Must Get Out of Buying Twitter?Links to an external site. – (24 minute podcast)
The Daily, NYT
Discussion of Musk and Twitter
Settimana 10
Week 10 - M&A Law
Asynchonous lesson:
Appraisal right
Enhanced fiduciary dutie
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Podcast
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Schuster, The Mandatory Bid Rule: Efficient, After All?, available at https://www.jstor.org/stable/41857485#metadata_info_tab_contentsLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: Unocal Corp. v. Mesa Petroleum Co.
Case 2: Moran v. Household International, Inc.
Case 3: Revlon, Inc. v. MacAndrews and Forbes Holdings, Inc.
Additional Material (about 50mn.):
Pills and CEOs Under Fire as M&A FadesLinks to an external site.
Only Study review of poison pills, start @ 31:58; end @ 37:06
Tech Monopolies: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (@ 0:55)Links to an external site.– (25 minute video)
Begins @ 0:55;
AT&T example @ (3:00)Links to an external site.
Apple (@ 5:57)Links to an external site.
Google (@ 8:48)Links to an external site.
Amazon (@ 15:29)Links to an external site.
Drinks With the Deal: Katten’s Kimerly SmithLinks to an external site. – (23 minute podcast)
The Deal Podcast (2022)
Settimana 11
Week 11 - Executive Compensation
Asynchonous lesson:
Pay for performance
Compensation components
Duty of good faith?
E-tivities
Readings
Cases
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: Lecture slides.
Reading 2: Bebchuk and Fried, Pay Without Performance: Overview of the Issues, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=761970Links to an external site.
Reading 3: Sepe et al., Executive Compensation Redux (only 207-236), available at https://texaslawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Sepe.pdfLinks to an external site.
Cases:
Case 1: In Re The Walt Disney Company Derivative Litigation
Additional Material (about 50 mn.):
CEOs Get Paid Too Much, According to. . .Everyone in the WorldLinks to an external site. – (3 minute video)
Harvard Business Review (2015)
Here’s Why Top CEOs Make More Than 100x Than Their WorkersLinks to an external site. – (12 minute video)
CNBC (2022)
Provides a progressive counter to 2nd WSJ (new) article below
What People Don’t Realize About High CEO PayLinks to an external site.– (5 minute video)
Thomas Sowell
Bebchuk – Executive Compensation (2009)Links to an external site. – (5 minute video)
Senate Finance Committee Hearing – Executive Compensation
Pay Packages for CEOs Rise to Record LevelLinks to an external site. – (13 minute read)
WSJ (2022)
Surveys current landscape of CEOs and the makeup of their compensation packages
Is There a Relationship Between High CEO Pay and Corporate Effectiveness?Links to an external site. – (7 minute read)
WSJ (2022)
Why CEOs Actually Deserve Their Gazillion-Dollar SalariesLinks to an external site. – (5-7 minute read)
Tyler Cowen (2019)
Settimana 12
Week 12 - CSR & ESG
Asynchonous lesson:
Corporate Social Responsibility – Rise and Evolution
Environmental, Social and Governance Criteria
Social Engagement or Political Activism?
E-tivities
Readings
Podcasts
Videos
Readings:
Reading 1: The Friedman’s Principle – The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits, available at https://www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctrine-the-social-responsibility-of-business-is-to.html.
Reading 2: Benabou and Tirole, Individual and Corporate Social Responsibility, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1573694Links to an external site. (only intro and part on corporate social responsibility)
Reading 3: Masconale & Sepe, Citizen Corp., available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3793035 (part V excluded).
Additional Material (about 60mn):
CSR & ESG in 4 minutesLinks to an external site.– (4 minute video)
No. 335 - Does Doing Good Give You License to Be Bad?Links to an external site. - (39 minute podcast)
Freakanomics radio (2018)
"Inclusive Capitalism & Moral Leadership - with Jacqueline NovogratzLinks to an external site. - (32 minute podcast)
Start @ 17:20; end @ 49:08
What is the difference between CSR and ESG?Links to an external site. – (5 minute read)
Maybe There’s No Such Thing as an ESG StockLinks to an external site. – (5 minute read)
Bloomberg (2022)
Companies Integrate CSR Initiatives into Everyday BusinessLinks to an external site. – (11 minute read)
Wharton – Business Journal (2012)