HISTORY OF LAW

Ferdinando Treggiari

Instructional goals

Examining the transformations undergone by law in history, the course aims to foster an awareness of the development and also the relativity and development of ant legal phenomenon. This kind of approach to legal history, which isn't focused just only on notions and dates, aims to train to independence of judgment and offer the right critical eye under which observe the developing and relativity of law.

Prerequisites

None

Intended learning outcomes

The course aims at enabling students to reach the following educational goals: 1) Knowledge and understanding: the course is meant to provide the student with an array of knowledge aimed at fostering a correct approach to the legal phenomenon, providing also a comprehensive overview of the evolution and transformation which law underwent through the centuries. The objective is to underline the quintessentially historic dimension of law and to stress the importance of a well-focused historical interpretation of the present legal framework. 2) Applying knowledge and understanding: the knowledge so acquired allow to develop a significant ability to critically analyse and to thoroughly understand legal text, improving the application of legal rules and the reasonable solution of controversies; moreover, they foster independence of mind and, through a sound critical thinking, they allow to represent the complexity of the legal phenomenon. The course aims at enabling students to reach the following educational goals: 1) Knowledge and understanding: the course is meant to provide the student with an array of knowledge aimed at fostering a correct approach to the legal phenomenon, providing also a comprehensive overview of the evolution and transformation which law underwent through the centuries. The objective is to underline the quintessentially historic dimension of law and to stress the importance of a well-focused historical interpretation of the present legal framework. 2) Applying knowledge and understanding: the knowledge so acquired allow to develop a significant ability to critically analyse and to thoroughly understand legal text, improving the application of legal rules and the reasonable solution of controversies; moreover, they foster independence of mind and, through a sound critical thinking, they allow to represent the complexity of the legal phenomenon. 3) Making judgments: acquisition of an high standard of independent analysis and judgement on legal problems and of methodologies and tools useful to gather, interpret and apply legal sources, so as to apply them independently and in an original way in order to scrutinize the issues which the student will be called to handle along the subsequent path of legal studies and in the working environment. In particular, competences of critical thinking, problem solving, self-management, team work, relational and communicative skills will all be adequately developed; these skills will reinforce curricular competences and make them more spendable on the market. Through the collection and the interpretation of all information on the historical evolution of legal concepts and an European comparative vision, using the methodological approach proper of a philosophical and historical approach, the student will master reasoning and put it to its best use towards innovative and original solutions. 4) Communication skills: acquisition of legal vocabulary, of an high level of terminological accuracy and of an appropriate rhetorical and debating skill in both, oral and written communication. 5) Learning skills: ability to point out and interpret any regulatory innovation and new judicial or academic approaches, through the lenses of historical evolution. Acquisition – also through case-studies – of a degree of knowledge apt to develop autonomous learning skills, which will allow the student to continue updating his competences, even independently.

Course Contents

The subject concerns the analysis of legal experiences (private and public law; international and criminal law) from the ancient world to the contemporary age, with specific reference to both the sources of law (judicial and legislative) as to the doctrine. Particular attention will be paid also to the evolution of the system of legal sources between state law and supranational law in the XXI century. The knowledge that will emerge from the course will not be enclosed in yesterday, but reconciled with the dynamics of contemporary society, filtered through special glasses, those of the legal history scolar.

Reference Books

Students attending lectures are required to study: – R. FERRARI ZUMBINI, Il grande giudice, Luiss University Press, 2 ed., 2024, (limited to the chapters suggested during the classes); and, alternately: - AA.VV. (a cura dì A. Cassi), "Le danze di Clio e Astrea. Fondamenti storici del diritto europeo", Giappichelli, 2023, limited to Chapters II and III for Part I and Chapters II (limited to sub-chapters from 4 to 11) and IV for Part II; OR - AA.VV. (a cura di E. Tavilla), "Tempi del diritto. Età medievale, moderna, contemporanea", Giappichelli, III ed., 2022, limited to Chapters I, II, III, IV e VIII. For students who aren't attending lectures it's also required the study of: - L. Lacchè, “La costituzione nel Novecento. Percorsi storici e vicissitudini dello Stato di diritto”, Giappichelli, 2023.

Teaching Methods

Lectures, tutorials, seminars

Assessment Method

Oral exam, during which the student will be required to show that he/she knows and understands the major issues underlying the historical trajectory of law in Western civilization from the middle ages to the present day, as they were expounded during the course and the seminars, if the student has been attending, with a specific focus on the legal systems which, over time, have been characterizing the juridical experience in the Italian peninsula. The student will be required to show that he/she is able to handle the categories regarding the themes of (i) sources, (ii) institutions, (iii) legal thought, using the appropriate technical and legal vocabulary and thus proving that he/she has acquired an adequate ability to contextualize, and an adequate study method and learning ability, in order to carry on, also independently, a basic orientation on the diachronic perspective of evolution of contemporary legal systems, being able to grasp a fundamental aspect of the legal phenomenon, that is historicity. The following evaluation criteria will be taken into account to assign the final grade, expressed in thirtieths: - knowledge and understanding of the evolution of sources, institutions, legal thought (55%); appropriate use of the technical and legal vocabulary, ability to focus on relevant information (acquisition of the study method) (25%), ability to contextualize historically and to evaluate law as an historical phenomenon (20%). Learning gaps concerning one or more notions or principles will lead to an insufficient evaluation.

Thesis assignment criteria

For the current academic year thesis involving Italian and European privat law history issues are preferred.

Week 1

The transition from the ancient world to the Middle Ages. The ultractivity of Roman law. From Constantine to Justinian (4th-6th centuries). The codifications of roman law. The Church. Leges and iura. The law of Citations. The codifications of the Late Empire. Gelasian dualism. The papal law.

Week 2

The irruption of Germanic peoples in Italy. Roman-Barbarian kingdoms and laws. The principle of personality of laws in the early Middle Ages. Visigothic and Burgundian legislation. The Edict of Theodoric. The Corpus Iuris Civilis. The coexistence of different laws. Customary law. Lombard law collections. The Carolingian age. Promissio Carisiaca. Donation of Constantine. From Gelasian dualism to universalism. Carolingian legislation. Justinian sources in the early Middle Ages. The Summa Perusina. The feud. Commendatio, homagium, fidelitas. Feudal customs. 'Dominium divisum'. The Dictatus Papae. Territorial orders. The relationship between lex and consuetudo. The reemergence of the Digest.

Week 3

'Civitas sibi princeps'. City as a legal system. The forms of city government. 'Iurisdictio': the l. Omnes populi. The sources of ius proprium: customs, statutes, royal law. Structure of the statute. The relations between iura propria and ius commune.

Week 4

The Legal Renaissance. Irnerio and the School of Bologna. The universitas scholarium. Rhetoric and the law: the modi arguendi. Glossators and Postglossators. The Glossa Magna. The Commentators. Medieval political doctrines. Canon law and the Church after Worms. The Decree of Gratian. From Gregory IX to the Corpus iuris canonici. Utrumque ius and his relationship with iura propria. Aequitas. Interpretatio.

Week 5

The consilia. Legal humanism. Law sources between the late Middle Ages and the early modern ages. Territorial states of Europe. The 'Grandi Tribunali’. Jusnaturalism: toward a more rational legal order.

Week 6

The Enlightenment: Beccaria. The Declarations of Rights. The law of the French Revolution. The concept of 'code'. The Code Napoleon. Codifications in Europe: ther Austrian and Prussian areas. The Italian area. The age of the Restoration. The 'Codice Pisanelli'.

Week 7

Constitutions. Conceptions of sovereignty. Medieval constitutionalism. The Magna Carta. The French constitutions of the late eighteenth century. Italian Jacobin constitutions. The Spanish and Sicilian constitutions of 1812. The Belgian constitution of 1830. The '48. Fundamental rights. The Statuto of Regno di Sardegna (1848).

Week 8

Law and legal science in Germany until the BGB (1900). Italian Codice civile 1942. Private law and the Constitution.

Week 9

Criminal law from Beccaria to the Italian codification of 1930

Week 10

Legal theories between the 19th and 20th century, on both shores of the Atlantic.

Week 11

Themes and problems discussed in the book 'Il grande giudice'

Week 12

Themes and problems discussed in the book 'Il grande giudice' (2)