HISTORY OF LAW
Instructional goals
The aim of the course is to introduce students to the complexity of a European vision of law. The unit seeks to select some of the main legal phenomena in the European history of law, providing the students with the information and skills needed to understand the historical roots of civil and common law. The course will try to extend the historical understanding of students as regards other legal systems, and developing in particular a critical overview of European legal traditions.
Intended learning outcomes
Knowledge and understanding
The course will offer an institutional viewpoint. The student will have a complete knowledge of the main profiles of the European legal experience between the Middle Ages and the contemporary era. The peculiar features of ius commune legal world in the Middle ages and in the changed sceneries of the modern period will be illustrated. The course will then be centred on the outlining of a new conception of the legal order between the Natural Law theories and the Enlightenment and on its realisation which will be made in the 19th century by way of the affirmation of legal systems with codified law. Special attention will be given to the trends and the role of the juridical science
Applying knowledge and understanding:
The students will be able to:
- Analyze legal phenomena from a historical-legal point of view;
- Develop a comparative legal history approach;
- Be accustomed to concepts useful to understand in a better way current legal trends and changes (global and transnational law, pluralistic legal mind etc.)
Making judgements:
The student will be able to analyze in-depth legal phenomena developing a critical understanding
The student will be able to reflect and to discuss legal-historical key concepts.
Communications Skills:
The student will understand major terms and concepts
in order to communicate appropriately their ideas, proposals, analysis and critical reasoning in the field of legal history and legal culture.
Learning skills:
The student will have some critical tools to understand a bit better why and how contemporay societies are marked by legal issues.
Course Contents
The course deals with the basic aspects of European legal history. Following the comparative legal history approach, it will present some key-elements: among them, Ius commune/Common Law traditions, legal Humanism, Natural Law, Law of Reason, Codifications, main legal trends and Schools.
Reference Books
Students attending lectures are required to study Antonio Padoa Schioppa, A History of Law in Europe. From the Early Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2018, pages from 1 to 23; 71 to 293, 342 to 574, 585 to 616.
Materials (slides) will be suggested during classes
Teaching Methods
The Professor will give lectures in order to present and explain the most important aspects of the course. In addition to this, there will be organized tutorials and seminars for students, using papers and powerpoint presentations, in classroom
Assessment Method
The examination will be written (100%).
The examination, which will last 1 hours 30 minutes, will consist in
answering written (closed and open) questions. During the written exam the student will be required to show that he/she knows and understands basic notions and concepts of Legal history and that he/she is able to use them as a critical tool to understand better the complexity and depth of legal phenomena. The student is expected to be able to analyze main sources and relevant categories of Legal history, thus proving that he/she has acquired the study method and the learning ability for carrying on, also independently, further study of the matter.
The following evaluation criteria will be taken into account to assign the final grade, expressed in thirtieths: - knowledge and understanding of the notions and concepts of the matter and ability to use them to build up a basic legal culture (75%); appropriate use of English as means of communication and legal vocabulary, ability to analyze and evaluate relevant sources and acquisition of the study method (25%).
Learning gaps concerning one or more notions or concepts will lead to an insufficient evaluation, even in presence of a basic knowledge of the matter.
Thesis assignment criteria
For the current academic year thesis involving european history issues are preferred.
Week 1
Session 1
Introduction. Why and how legal history can contribute to the training of the law student. The concept of historicity. Understanding different legal contexts
Session 2 Constitutive structures: foundations of Roman law to understand the medieval legal tradition
Week 2
Session 1
Constitutive structures: Customary Law, Canon Law
Session 2 The Ius commune tradition: the birth of medieval Universities and legal science
Week 3
Session 1
(following) The Ius commune tradition: the birth of medieval Universities and legal science
Seminar: research methodologies (with students practical training)
Session 2 Common Law: origins, features, dimensions
Week 4
Session 1
Common Law: developments; equity system
Seminar: research methodologies (with students practical training)
Session 2 Legal humanism.
Week 5
Session 1
Common Law: developments;
Seminar: research methodologies (with students practical training) system
Session 2 Legal humanism.
Week 6
Session 1
Legal Rationalism: introduction. Legal voluntarism: Pufendorf, Thomasius
Session 2
Legal Rationalism: Leibniz and Wolff; French trends: Domat, Pothier
Week 7
Session 1
Criminal Reform and Criminal Justice in the European Enlightenment
Session 2
Consolidation, Code, Codification.
Week 8
Session 1
The Many Faces of the Codification of Law in Modern Europe: Prussian General Code (1794)
Seminar: presentation by students of the research carried out (paper and powerpoint)
Session 2
The Many Faces of the Codification of Law in Modern Europe: French Civil Code (1804)
Week 9
Session 1
The Many Faces of the Codification of Law in Modern Europe: French Civil Code (1804)
Seminar: presentation by students of the research carried out (paper and powerpoint)
Session 2
Criminal Law Codes: examples
Week 10
Session 1
1814-1815: Dilemmas of Restoration. The controversy between Thibaut and Savigny in 1814.
Seminar: presentation by students of the research carried out (paper and powerpoint) Session 2
Legal science trends. Science of the Pandects
Week 11
Session 1
Science of Pandects and the German Civil
Code Seminar: presentation by students of the research carried out (paper and powerpoint)
Session 2
The Italian Civil Code (1865)
Week 12
Session on campus
The Italian Criminal Law Codification process (1865-1889)
Session 2
Liberal, Social and Authoritarian Foundations of Criminal Law in Italy