HISTORY AND POLITICAL SOCIOLOGY OF FRANCE AND ITALY
Instructional goals
This course aims to study politics in France and Italy from 1945 to the present day. It starts from an observation. The French think they know Italy and the Italians, but they convey a lot of clichés about the other country and its inhabitants, and even more about politics in this country. The same goes for the French. Foreigners often share these stereotypes. For example, Italian democracy would be corrupt, clientelist, abnormal, while France would be a republican, authoritarian, centralized and arrogant monarchy. This course intends to destroy these outrageous simplifications. It aims to study the institutions, party systems and political parties, voting mechanisms, cultures and political identities in France and Italy, while following the political evolutions of the two countries over nearly 80 years. It will address the most recent changes in French and Italian democracies, what is sometimes called the "crisis" of democracies with citizens' distrust of politics, their indifference, or their protests against the political classes, their demands for authority or, conversely, for more participative democracy. The central thesis of the course is to go against mainstream interpretations of Italian and French politics, according to which Italian democracy is abnormal and France an exception. Without denying the singularities of the two countries, their histories, their institutional characteristics, the similarities of the present changes of the two democracies and the challenges they must meet will be highlighted. The other originality of the course is that it is located at the crossroads of history and political science: on the one hand, it will defend a conceptual, social and cultural history of politics, and on the other a historical sociology. Indeed, according to us, politics can only be understood in its permanent interaction with the transformations of society and culture. Politics determines changes in society and culture, but is also affected by changes in them. France and Italy are excellent points of observation of these phenomena
Intended learning outcomes
The students will gain full knowledge of Politics in France and Italy. That’s the reason why during the first session of the first week, we will start from the students' initial knowledge of politics in France and Italy, this exercise which could take the form of a little game intellectual will not be noted. It will allow the Professor to adjust the level of the different lessons. The course aims to provide a solid knowledge of institutions, the system of parties and political parties, voting mechanisms but also cultures and political identities as they have gradually been built but also by analyzing their decomposition. The goal is to understand and will not be accepted value judgments or ideological and politically biased analyses. The course will have a conceptual dimension, and an empirical dimension and contextualization will be systematically considered. We will not content ourselves with analyzing each case study, France and Italy, and we will systematically make comparisons between the two countries, as we will seek to determine whether French policy has been able to influence or still influences the Italian politics and vice versa.
The objective for students is to master the forms taken by politics in France and Italy. This could be useful to them in their future professional life in the private sector, which must always at some point take into consideration the political sphere, for consulting jobs, in institutions, diplomacy, community life, politics for those who are destined for it, journalism, the world of culture or the academic carriers.
The pedagogy adopted will be a mix of lectures and, according to the importance of the audience, some or continuous interaction with students. Each week the first course will be a general presentation of a precise topic by the professor followed by a discussion more or less extended with the students based on a text they must read and comment on. The second session begins with an intervention by the professor who finishes the presentation of the first session, answering eventual questions by the students, and followed by a course organized around an essay question.
Students must read the readings each week for the first course but also submit during the course one position papers of 300 words on the reading to be done for the first course or on the question discussed in the second session of the week.
A midterm written exam will be organized. It will be an essay question of 45 minutes in class (verifier si c’est possible) and after the exam a general briefing of the exam will be done. This midterm exam as the final exam supposed a permanent presence of the students in class and a good knowledge of the texts they have to read.
In addition, at the end of the course, a final written exam of one hour will be organized. It will be an essay question. To pass this exam the students must be present at all the sessions of the courses and read all the texts.
For all these reasons, this course cannot be choosen by non-attending students.
Course Contents
The course will last from February 2nd to May 9th 2026
It’s organized each week in two sessions of interactive pedagogy
The first session begins with an intervention by the professor followed by a discussion with the students based on a text they must read and comment on.
The second session begins with an intervention by the professor who finish the presentation of the first session followed by a discussion with the students who must answer to a essay question. More information on the document “Course overview”
Reference Books
Papers and articles
Teaching Methods
Teaching methods
The pedagogy adopted will be a mix of lectures and continuous interaction with students.
There is not a Handbook on politics in France and Italy. It means the students must read the text each week for the discussion in class for the first session of the course about the readings and must be regularly present in class.
Each week, during the second session of the course, there is a summary or a complement of the first session of the course by prof. Marc Lazar then one hour session during which the students will have all together to answer a question.
Assessment Method
The students will have to read the lecture each week but also each student will have to submit two position papers of 300 words during the course, one on the reading to be done for the course, the other on the subject discussed in the Wednesday’s session so called “answering a question”.
The position papers based on the readings for the first course of the week consist not of a summary of the texts to be read but of indicating the points that the students do not understand or want to explore in depth or that they criticize.
The position papers for the second course of the week consist of a personal answer to the question asked and based as much as possible on readings.
During the second week of course, all the students will have to choose the position papers they will do.
The position paper for the first course of the course will have to be sent to prof. Marc Lazar some days before (the official date will be given later).
The position paper for the second course of the course will have to be sent to prof. Marc Lazar one day before.
In addition, at the end of the course, the students will have to submit a research paper of 3000 words (including the bibliography) on one of the subjects that the professor will give at midterm of the course. There is a possibility to write a paper on a topic proposed by the student with the agreement by the professor.
The final paper will have to be sent one week after the end of the course (the precise date will be given later). The deadline must be respected. Each day of eventual delay will be sanctioned by one point less.
In addition, the oral participation of the students will be evaluated by the professor during all the course and more especially for the collective work realized by the groups of students during the last sessions (weeks 13th and 14th).
The position papers will form 30% of the final grade, the oral participation 20% and the final paper 50%. For the students who read Italian and/or French, some texts in these languages could be given instead of the English ones. This decision will be made at the end of the first week.
All written assignments (papers position and final paper) must be double-spaced in Times New Roman. Please include page numbers. Type your full name on the first page of the document. Name the file (in .doc) with your last name (e.g., Lazar-paperposition.doc, Lazar- finalpaper.doc).
Thesis assignment criteria
The students will have to read the lecture each week but also each student will have to submit two position papers of 300 words during the course, one on the reading to be done for the course, the other on the subject discussed in the Wednesday’s session so called “answering a question”.
The position papers based on the readings for the first course of the week consist not of a summary of the texts to be read but of indicating the points that the students do not understand or want to explore in depth or that they criticize.
The position papers for the second course of the week consist of a personal answer to the question asked and based as much as possible on readings.
During the second week of course, all the students will have to choose the position papers they will do.
The position paper for the first course of the course will have to be sent to prof. Marc Lazar some days before (the official date will be given later).
The position paper for the second course of the course will have to be sent to prof. Marc Lazar one day before.
In addition, at the end of the course, the students will have to submit a research paper of 3000 words (including the bibliography) on one of the subjects that the professor will give at midterm of the course. There is a possibility to write a paper on a topic proposed by the student with the agreement by the professor.
The final paper will have to be sent one week after the end of the course (the precise date will be given later). The deadline must be respected. Each day of eventual delay will be sanctioned by one point less.
In addition, the oral participation of the students will be evaluated by the professor during all the course and more especially for the collective work realized by the groups of students during the last sessions (weeks 13th and 14th).
The position papers will form 30% of the final grade, the oral participation 20% and the final paper 50%. For the students who read Italian and/or French, some texts in these languages could be given instead of the English ones. This decision will be made at the end of the first week.
All written assignments (papers position and final paper) must be double-spaced in Times New Roman. Please include page numbers. Type your full name on the first page of the document. Name the file (in .doc) with your last name (e.g., Lazar-paperposition.doc, Lazar- finalpaper.doc).
Week 1
First Course : Politics in France and Italy. Against Reciprocal Stereotypes, the Necessity of an Academic Approach.
• A first session will be based on active interaction with the students.
• All together, we will identify some stereotypes on France and especially on French politics by Italians, of Italy and especially on Italian politics by French people.
• Likewise, we will seek together to understand this strange relationship between two countries which frequently declare themselves “Latin cousins” but which are often very distant, especially in political matters. This refers to a relationship of love and distrust that is part of a quite long history.
• Then always in a permanent interaction with the class we will investigate on the level of basic knowledge of the students of Italian and French politics from 1945 to our days. This little exercise, considered as a kind of intellectual game which will not be evaluated, will allow the Professor to adjust the rest of the course sessions.
• The second session will be devoted to clarifying what the professor means by a history and a political sociology of France and Italy. It will present the complex relationships that exist between history and sociology and will show how the hybridization between them can be achieved for a better understanding of politics in France and Italy. It is a question of practicing both a conceptual, social and cultural history of politics and a historical sociology.
• Finally, the teacher will present the course, justify the choice of sessions, explain the teaching method.
Second course:
Summary of first course and questions by students
One exercise with the class (essay question)
• We will try all together to identify some recurrent political polemics between France and Italy and to explain them.
Lectures Content:
• Stefano Cavazza, « Suspicious Brothers. Reflections on Political History and Social Sciences », Ricerche di storia politica, October 2017, p. 53-63 (tbc)
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor
Week 2
First course : The Fourth French Republic (1946-1958)
• The conditions of the creation of the Fourth Republic
• The institutions of the Fourth Republic
• The main chronological sequences of the Fourth Republic
• The end of the Fourth Republic, its causes, and its consequences
Second course:
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Why the Fourth Republic is very often considered as a Republic “mal aimée”, a “disliked Republic”?
Lectures content:
• Herrick Chapman, France Long Reconstruction : In Search of the Modern Republic, Harvard, Harvard University Press, 2018, p. 1-16.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor
Week 3
First course : Italian Republic and its evolutions 1946-1990s
• From Fascism to the Republic
• The Institutions of the Italian Republic
• The main sequences of the Italian Republic from 1946 to 1990s
• The limits and the success of the Italian Republic
• Does the Italian Republic have been an anomaly?
Second course:
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• What has been the foreign mainstream perception of Italian politics until the 1990s?
Lectures content:
• James L. Newell, « A ‘Blocked’ political system: Politics in the First Republic» in James L. Newell, Italy’s Contemporary Politics, New York, Routledge, 2023, chapter 2: https://www.perlego.com/book/2014024/italys-contemporary-politics-pdf
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor
Week 4
First course : The French Fifth Republic from 1958 to the 1980s-1990s
• The conditions of the creation of the Fifth Republic
• The institutions and their evolutions
• The main sequences of the Fifth Republic
• Greatness and Dysfunction of the Fifth Republic
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Does the Fifth Republic could be an example and even a model for the Italian Republic ?
Lectures content:
• Gérard Grunberg, « The French Party System and the Crisis of Representation », in Pepper Culdepper, Peter Hall, Bruno Palier, Changing France. The politics That Market Make, London, Palgrave Macmilan, 2006, p. 223-244.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor
Week 5
First course : Comparative Study of the Political Parties in France and Italy (1)
• Italian “Partitocracy” and weakness of the political parties in France
• Study of the main political parties of the two countries. A focus on some political families. The Christian Democracy
• The far right in Italy and in France
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• What has been the impact of Vatican II on the Catholicism and their relations with politics in France and Italy?
Lectures content:
• Percy Allum, « ‘From to One’. The Faces of the Italian Christian Democracy Party », Party Politics, vol. 3, n°1, 1997, p. 23-52
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor
Week 6
First course : Comparative study of the political parties in France and in Italy (2)
• A focus on some political families.
• The Communist Parties
• The Socialist Parties
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• François Mitterrand and Bettino Craxi: which Socialist leaders were they?
Lectures content:
• Marc Lazar, « The French Communist Party » in Norman Naimark, Silvio Pons, Sophie Quinn-Judge (eds), The Cambridge History of Communism, volume II. The Socialist Camp and World Power 1941-1960s, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2017, p. 619-641
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 7
First course : The Importance of Political Culture and Identities in French and Italian Politics
• What do we mean by Political Culture and Identities? A theoretical approach and empirical realities.
• Some territorial examples in Italy and France.
• Importance and decline of the Political Culture and Identities: which explanation can we give?
• Examples of strong cultural antagonisms in France and Italy: Fascism and antifascism; Communism and anticommunism.
• Second course :
• Summary of the first course and questions by students
• One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Does French nationalism is always important after World War II?
Lectures content:
• Carlo Trigilia, « Small-Firm Development and Political Subcultures in Italy», European Sociological Review, vol. 2, n°3, December 1986, p. 161-175. (tbc)
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 8
First course : A Comparative Perspective
• The end of the “First” Italian Republic
• The mutation of the Fifth Republic in the 1990s and in 2017
• Transformations of political parties
• Mistrust, distrust, and defiance in politics
• Personalization and mediatization of politics
• Mutations of the societies and divorce with politics
• Convergences and differences between France and Italy
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Do Silvio Berlusconi and berlusconism have been an anomaly ?
Lectures content:
• Andrew Knapp, « France’s party system in 2022 », Modern and Contemporary France, 30.4, 2022, p. 13-33.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 9
First course : The great challenge of populism (1)
• Questions of definition. What is populism? A conceptual approach in political science and history.
• Populism of the past in France and in Italy. Examples: “L’Uomo qualunque” in Italy, the “poujadistes” in France, the Maoists in France and Italy
Second course:
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Why these populisms of the past seem to have been mere bouts of fever?
Lectures content:
• Cas Mudde, Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser, « What Is Populism ?» in Cas Mudde, Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser, A Very Short History of Populism, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2017, p. 1-20.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 10
First course : the great challenge of populism (2)
• Radical right parties and movements in France and Italy
• Radical Left in France
• 5 stars Movement in Italy
• Common points and differences between populists
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• What are the common points and the differences between the neo-populist movements, parties and leaders and the populists of the past in France and Italy?
Lectures content:
• Leonardo Puleo, Gianluca Piccolini, « Back to the Past. Fascist Past or Landing in the Populist Radical Right? », South European Politics and Society, September 2022, Published online, p. 1-25.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 11
First course : The Mutations of the Democracy in France and Italy
• The different challenges for the democracy
• Requests for authority and expectations for more democracy
• Are there risks for the French and Italian Democracy?
• Is there a possibility of a comeback of Fascism in Italy and a return to the . Fourth Republic in France?
• Indifference to politics and hyper politicization
• Protest and violence in Politics.
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students (essay question)
•To resolve the democratic crisis, do we need to change the institutions in Italy and change the Constitution in France?
Lectures content:
• Yasha Mounk, « The Crisis of Liberal Democracy » in Yasha Mounk, The People vs Democracy. Why Our Freedom Is in Danger and How to Save It, Harvard, Harvard University Press, 2018, p. 24-45.
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Week 12
First course : France and Italy : specificities and common characteristics
• What’s about French exceptionalism?
• What’s about the “anomalous” Italian democracy?
Lectures content:
• Mark Gilbert, Italy Reborn: from fascism to democracy, New York, Norton & Company, 2024, p.. (tbc).
• Additional teaching materials provided by the professor.
Second course :
Summary of the first course and questions by students
One question to discuss with the class (essay question)
• Could France be a model for Italy and could Italy be a model for France?