GOVERNANCE OF INNOVATION & CLIMATE CHANGE

GOVERNANCE OF INNOVATION & CLIMATE CHANGE

Elena De Nictolis, Amnon Lehavi

Instructional goals

Governance of Innovation and Climate change is an interdisciplinary core course that has the ambition to bridge from theories to practice. Therefore, it has a strong interactive and applied challenge-based study component. That is why it is taught by adjunct and visiting professors that have a strong interdisciplinary bent that merges strategic planning background with social sciences from which to draw the ability to develop hybrid interpretative reflections in order to accomplish the processes of ecological and digital transformation through multi-actor collaboration. The course focuses on cutting-edge challenges in governance research, with specific subjects covered through multidisciplinary seminars readings and broad in-class debate. The course encourages teachers and graduate students to do cross-disciplinary, collaborative, and problem-based research. It also focuses on experimentalism, to adjust novel solutions. The course will have strong synergies with the X-Labs referring to representatives of community actors, public and commercial actors to conduct simulations and build prototypes of successful policies and programs with the aim to address critical concerns in the governance of innovation (research-based innovation; innovation generated by policy experiments; social innovation), climate change and planetary boundaries (also in relation to the targets and goals set by international agencies; social, environmental and climate justice; community-based local development). The idea is to stimulate new ways of thinking of conscious thinking. Therefore, the course's ultimate goal is to provide students with the analytical tools for qualitative and quantitative analysis, as well as the knowledge to understand the process of governance of innovation and climate change from the perspectives of multi-stakeholder decision-making and public policy-making at both the local and international levels.

Intended learning outcomes

Knowledge and understanding: - By the end of the course, students should be able to: • Analyze, discuss, and debate some of the policy areas concerning innovation and sustainability that are the most challenging for many national and local governments; • Identify and obtain a basic understanding of the main legal issues affecting national and local government authority to set policy across a variety of substantive areas concerning sustainability and innovation. Insights to use: - After completing the study program, students will be able to: • assess and interpret different hypotheses explaining key environmental, economic, political, legal, and social developments related to innovation and climate change; and • evaluate the impact of future changes in the policy framework to regulate pressing social and economic challenges related to the innovation and sustainability ecosystem. Making decisions: - After completing the study program, students will be able to: • prepare original challenge-based research supported by relevant bibliography and data analysis, and debate different perspectives on the issue; • articulate and explore economic, political, sociological, and historical factors that bear on significant policy concerns confronting policymakers and policy communities throughout the world on the themes of innovation and climate change. Students will be able to: • convey policy-relevant concepts, both orally, graphically, and in writing, after finishing the study program; • interact within groups and with practitioners; • construct through the lab an analytic stakeholder mapping, legal by design toolbox, co-cycles and conflicts resolution strategies

Course Contents

This course will look at a variety of policy and legal issues that policymakers are currently dealing with when it comes to the governance of innovation and climate change, ranging from territorial and urban issues (i.e. innovative efforts to encourage economic development and implement strategies to expand tech-based social justice) to global issues (i.e. environmental justice concerns; the implementation of global agenda on sustainable developments among others). The following topics will be addressed: • introduction as well as theoretical lenses - different definitions of governance for innovation and sustainability; • polycentricity and stewardship as design principles for governance; • economic governance, governance of sustainable development, integrated development, strategic planning • democratic governance; • social and technical justice; • risk governance, environmental and climate justice; • the importance of cities and innovation ecosystems; • experimentalist governance; • co-governance, legal mechanisms, and multi-stakeholder collaboration on innovation and climate change. The lab will provide governance answers to concrete challenges identified by students during the first part of the course.

Reference Books

Teaching Methods

Assessment Method

70% 10% class attendance and proactive participation to the readings based class discussion 30% in class assessment on Feb 16, exercise on Empirical Analysis of citizen sensing for environmental justice 30% in class assessment during the empirical analysis lab 30% Final essay. Take home exam to be submitted 8 days before the date of the exam session. A list of topics will be made available by the Professors. The essay must be submitted via learn.luiss. Please note that essays will be uploaded on Turnitin. The essay must be 1.500 words, reference included. Citation style is APA.

Thesis assignment criteria

No requisites

Week 1 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 1, Feb 8 & 9: Introduction to the course This week will be devoted to a general introduction to the course and to the course evaluation method. on February 9, the class will also host a lecture and a class discussion on the following questions that are at the core of the course: 1. what is governance ? 2. what is the governance of innovation and climate change, and why are these two topics above all others 3.. what is the governance of innovation and how to operationalize it? what components of innovation will the course touch? 4. introduction to the core principles and questions around the governance of climate change; the climate regime and climate international politics; climate change and global economy; the concept of climate change regulation at the transnational level; climate change law and its role within the governance of climate change at the global level.

Week 2 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 2, Feb 15 & 16: First class exercise On February 16, we will run an exercise guided by Dr. Anna Berti Suman. Anna is a Postdoc at the Luiss Law Department and she was recently a Marie Curie fellow at the Joint Research Center of the European Commission. Anna graduated in Law from the University of Bologna and holds a PhD in Law from the University of Tilburg. Anna will guide an exercise on the Fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis method, using a database developed by the European Commission of more than 500 cases of citizen science for environmental policy. Link to the dataset https://data.jrc.ec.europa.eu/dataset/jrc-citsci-10004 We ask that you please read the analysis that Anna developed in her book on Environmental Citizen sensing before class. Readings are required before class. The book is attached as a PDF file in the course material. Please focus on the following sections: Chapters 2 and 4, sections 4.4, 4.5 (until 4.5.3.2 included), and 4.6.

Week 3 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 3, Feb 22 & 23 Module on Governance of Urban innovation_1 This module will examine the various ways in which cities address challenges of governance while promoting innovation. It will particularly address how cities move beyond local and even national jurisdictions to compete - but also to collaborate - on the regional (such as across the European Union) and global levels. While until recently, a small number of cities stood out as “global cities,” more cities across the world are now exploring innovative strategies for physical and digital urban governance that transcends traditional boundaries. Session 1 - Friday, February 23, 2024 Moving forward: cities and urbanism in the 21st century Ran Hirschl, City, State: Constitutionalism and the Megacity (Oxford University Press, 2020), Introduction (pp. 1-15). Astrid Voorwinden, “The Privatised City: Technology and Public-Private Partnerships in the Smart City,” 13:2 Law, Innovation and Technology 439-463 (2021

Week 4 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 4, Feb 29 & Mar 1 Module on Governance of Urban Innovation_2 Session 2 – Friday, March 1, 2024 Innovation in land use, zoning, planning, and urban development Oliver Wainwright, “Super-tall, Super-skinny, Super-expensive: The ‘Pencil Towers’ of New York’s Super Rich,” The Guardian, February 5, 2019. Lewis Dijkstra, Hugo Poelman & Paolo Veneri, “The EU-OECD Definition of a Functional Urban Area,” OECD Regional Development Working Papers 2019/11.

Week 5 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 5, March 7 & 8 Transnational Climate Change law and its role in the governance of climate change 

Week 6 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 6, March 14 & 15 International Investment Treaties and the economics of climate change

Week 7 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 7, March 21 & 22 The EU climate policy. EU Clean Energy Package and the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism

Week 8 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 8, Mar 28 & 29, Empirical Analysis Lab_1

Week 9 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 10, April 11 & 12, Empirical Analysis Lab_3

Week 10 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 9, April 4 & 5, Empirical Analysis lab_2

Week 11 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Week 11, Apr 18 & 19, Empirical Analysis Lab_4 AND Module on innovation, globalization, and digitalization in property law_1 This module will discuss whether the emergence of new types of tangible or intangible resources, or of innovative practices for the creation, allocation, and governance of assets, challenges established concepts of property. Each such novelty may call into question if the traditional framework of property law can address the contemporary cross-border reality of governing various assets, such as land, digital assets, and cultural property. Session 1 – Friday, April 19, 2024 The role of markets, technology, and innovation in the globalization of property law Juliet M. Moringiello & Christopher K. Odinet, “The Property Law of Tokens,” 74 Florida Law Review 607 (2022). Amnon Lehavi, “From Global Databases to Global Norms? A Study of Cultural Property Law,” 44 University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law 359 (2023).

Week 12 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus

Wek 12, May 2 & 3, Module on innovation, globalization, and digitalization in property law_2 Creativity, copyright, and the right of publicity in the digital age Directive (EU) 2019/790 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 April 2019 on copyright and related rights in the Digital Single Market and amending Directives 96/9/EC and 2001/29/EC, O.J. L 130/92 (May 17, 2019). Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc v. Goldsmith (United States Supreme Court), 598 U.S. 508 (2023).