COMPARATIVE POLITICS
Instructional goals
To develop skills in the analysis of political systems in a comparative way and with sensitivity to the international dimensions of domestic politics. In other words, this is "open political economy" comparative politics.
Intended learning outcomes
Achieving a good command of methods of analysis of contemporary politics, complemented by the acquired knowledge of political macrophenomena, also through the help of example covering all main political phenomena of political change.
Course Contents
The course is divided into two separate parts. Following the first introductory week conducted by Professor Leonardi, Professor Tomasz Woźniakowski will take the lead during weeks 2 – 5. Professor Woźniakowski will cover cover the European Union in a comparative and historical perspective, the dynamics of the economic crises and their impact on multilevel government, and the role of institutions in comparative politics and international relations. The second part of the course taught by Professor Robert Leonardi (weeks 6 – 10) will analyse major European political systems covering the United Kingdom, France, Germany and Italy, in addition to a discussion of the emerging reality of the European Union.
Content of weeks 2 – 5:
Institutions are central to politics and political science. We can think of three interrelated factors operating in both domestic and international politics: power, ideas, and institutions. Ideas frame incentives and provide roadmaps for how to pursue them. Power provides the resources to channel non-market incentives (rents!), and institutions provide the framework of rules. The basic economic model is very close to this framework. Economics thinks in terms of preferences (incentives), endowments (resources), technology (ideas), and, after Douglass North, property rights (institutions) but conspicuously downplays power.
The course compares the American experience of fiscal integration which led to the creation of the federal power to tax (i.e. a fiscal union) with the European experience of fiscal regulation. The course analyzes the conditions under which a federal fiscal union is likely to emerge. What is the role of a crisis? Why is it justified to compare the modern EU and the pre-Constitution US? How does it help us to understand the nature of the multilevel government?
We focus on political institutions in both domestic and international politics within the context of the European Union. Why do fiscal and regulatory institutions at the EU level differ so much from those at the national level? Countries have the resources, the ideas, and the incentives, so why don’t they create the institutions at the EU level to make it less crisis prone, institutions that are more in line with those created in domestic politics? The readings explore the role of ideas (e.g ordo-liberalism vs. Keynesianism), national incentives (e.g. on mutualization of debt), and power (e.g. between the German-led north and the southern part of the Eurozone).
Content of weeks 6 – 10:
Weeks 6 – 10 of part II of the course will discuss the evolution of four major countries in Europe (United Kingdom, France, Germany and Italy), in order to understand the similarities and differences that exist among the four national models selected in terms of their institutions, distribution of political parties and major policies. The publication that will serve as the basis for the readings selected for the module is Donald Hancock (ed.) Politics in Europe, 7th edition, London: Sage, 2018) that presents a comparative analysis of seven European countries. Due to the time restrictions we will concentrate on four of the seven countries. However, if students are interested in the political systems of the other three countries—i.e., Russia, Poland and Sweden-- they are available in the text of the publication.
Reference Books
Part I of the course convened by Tomasz Woźniakowski will rely on two core textbooks:
S. Fabbrini, 2019, Europe’s Future: Decoupling and Reforming, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
S. Fabbrini, 2015. Which European Union? Europe After the Euro Crisis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
(both are available as e-book in the Luiss Library)
T. Woźniakowski, 2022, Fiscal Unions. Economic Integration in Europe and the United States, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
In order to access virtual books and articles, first you must edit the proxy configurations of your browser, and then you should open the source via the Luiss Library search engine.
Part II of the course convened by Professor Robert Leonardi will largely rely on the below core textbook:
Donald Hancock (ed.) Politics in Europe, 7th edition, London: Sage, 2018.
The Luiss Library has a hard copy of the book on reserve. The book can be read on the spot, no overnight loan is available.
Teaching Methods
Students will benefit from both lecture and interatcive, seminar-style teaching. The course includes a 45 mins online and 1hr 15 minutes in-person lecture. In addition, 1hr interactive breakout sessions (seminar-style teaching) will be organised in group division.
Please note that some lectures will be longer due to starting a week later than other first year magistrale courses. There will be no teaching on 1st November, Tuesday, which is bank holiday.
Assessment Method
100% end of year, take-home, open book exam
The exam covers the entire course, students will have to choose and answer two open-ended essay questions, which relate to the two separate sections of the course material. There will be no mid-term exams.
Exam answers will be checked for plagiarism via a software called Turnitin. The use of any text not originating from the author needs to be attributed to the original source. If it is a direct quotation it should be appropriately quoted and referenced, if it is a paraphrased quote, referencing is still required.
Thesis assignment criteria
No specific criteria, except the salience of the topic and the effective interest of the student.
Does the syllabus cover sustainability topics?
No
Week 1 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #1 Introduction to the course, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Robert Leonardi)
Week one will cover the logic of comparative analysis, comparative research designs, the differences between comparative and longitudinal designs, relationship between case studies, statistical designs, process tracing and comparative designs.
Readings:
Arendt Lijphart (1971), “Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method”, American Political Science Review, vo. 65, # 3, pp. 682-693.
Alexander George and Andrew Bennett (2005), “Case Studies and Theory Development”, chapter 1 of Case Studies and Theory Development, by A. George and A. Bennett, pp. 3-36.
David Collier (1993). “The Comparative Method”, in Ada Finifter (ed.). Political Science: the State of the Discipline. Washington, DC: APSA, pp. 105-119.
Leonardo Morlino (2018), Comparison: A Methodological Introduction for the Social Sciences, chapters 2-5.
Week #1 Process Tracing, mechanisms and comparative theory, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Lecture two will cover process tracing, how process tracing may enhance comparative designs, how process tracing and the idea of mechanism are connected.
James Caporaso, “Is There a Qualitative-Quantitative Divide in Comparative Politics? The Case of Process Tracing”, in Handbook of Comparative Politics, edited by Todd Landman and Neil Robinson, Sage Publications, 2009.
Alexander George and Andrew Bennett (2005), “Process Tracing and Historical Explanation”, in George and Bennett, Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences.,MIT Press, pp. 205-232.
John Gerring (2007). Case Study Research. Cambridge, England. Cambridge University Press, pp.178-185.
Week #1 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
What is the advantage of comparing the politics or political process in various countries?
Is it possible to have one political model for all countries?
Do politics matter?
Week 2 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #2 Institutionalization of the European Union. Perspectives on the EU, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week #2 Institutionalization of the European Union. Perspectives on the EU, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week 2 will cover the historical development of the European Union, its institutional framework and the different perspectives by which the EU could be analyzed.
Readings:
S. Fabbrini, Which European Union? Europe After the Euro Crisis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015 (Ch. 1, 4-5-6).
T. Woźniakowski, 2022, Fiscal Unions. Economic Integration in Europe and the United States, Oxford: Oxford University Press (Ch. 4)
Week #2 In-person seminar (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
What are the supranational features of the EU - provide evidence-based arguments. What are the economic gains from the single market? Does the Lisbon treaty provide proper institutional framework for the EU? Is the EU democratic? Was the euro crisis handled the right way? Is the solidarity the guiding principle of the EU response to the Corona crisis?
Week 3 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #3 Fiscal regimes of the EU and the US, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week #3 Fiscal regimes of the EU and the US, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week 3 contrasts the American experience of fiscal integration with the European one and subsequently concludes with the insights for the EU.
Readings
T. Woźniakowski, 2022, Fiscal Unions. Economic Integration in Europe and the United States, Oxford: Oxford University Press (Ch. 1 and 6)
S. Fabbrini, Europe’s Future. Decoupling and Reforming, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2019 (Ch. 5)
Week #3 In-person seminar (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
What are the similarities - and the differences - between the pre-Constitution US and the modern EU with regards to their fiscal arrangements? What are the conditions under which central level of government in the systems of multi-level government is likely to get a power to tax?
Week 4 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #4 Political Institutions: Domestic and international, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week #4 Political Institutions: Domestic and international, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Weeks 4 and 5 deal with institutions at the domestic and international level and asks how individual countries pursue their goals within a domestic and international environment (simultaneously) We focus in particular on the construction of regulatory and fiscal institutions at the domestic and European (EU) levels. What drives policy outcomes at the domestic and international levels? Power, preferences, ideas, and institutions are examined as potential explanations.
Week #4 Political Institutions: Domestic and international, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week #4 Political Institutions: Domestic and international, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Weeks 4 and 5 deal with institutions at the domestic and international level and asks how individual countries pursue their goals within a domestic and international environment (simultaneously) We focus in particular on the construction of regulatory and fiscal institutions at the domestic and European (EU) levels. What drives policy outcomes at the domestic and international levels? Power, preferences, ideas, and institutions are examined as potential explanations.
Readings
Jonathan Rodden (2003). “Soft Budget Constraints and German Federalism”, in Fiscal Decentralization and the Challenge of Hard Budget Constraints, edited by Jonathan Rodden, Gunnar Eskeland, and Jennie Litvack. Cambridge, Ma. MIT Press.pp. 161-186.
Tomasz Wozniakowski (2018). “Why the sovereign debt crisis could lead to a federal fiscal union: the paradoxical origins of fiscalization in the United States and insights for the European Union”, Journal of European Public Policy, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 630-649.
Paul DeGrauwe, (2011). “Managing a Fragile Eurozone”, CESTFO Forum, 2/2011, pp. 1-6.
Zsolt Darvas, (2010). Fiscal Federalism in Crisis: Lessons for Europe from the United States, Bruegel (Brussels), pp. 1-16.
Waltraud Schelkle (2009). “The Contentious Creation of a Regulatory State in Fiscal Surveillance”, West European Politics, vol. 32, no. 4, pp. 829-846.
Week #4 In-person seminar (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
Why are they important? What functions do they perform?: basic public goods, redistribution, equalization of incomes and consumption, stabilization of economy.
Week 5 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #5 Political Institutions (continued), online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Week #5 Political Institutions (continued), in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
The case for Ideational and Power Differences. In this section we explore the role of differences in ideas (in particular the role of monetary and fiscal policy at the international level) as well as differences in the organization of capitalism at the domestic level and power differences among states reflecting these domestic differences.
Readings
These three readings stress different aspects (and causes) of the financial crisis. Hall emphasizes institutional differences in the way capitalist systems are organized at the domestic level. Caporaso emphasizes Germany’s power, framed by its understanding of ordoliberalism and backed by its material advantages in the Eurozone. Brunnermeier and his coauthors stress the key role of ideas. Each of these factors does not operate independently of the others.
Peter Hall (2014). “Varieties of Capitalism and the Euro Crisis”, West European Politics, vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 341-369.
James Caporaso (2021). “Germany and the Eurozone Crisis: Power, Dominance and Hegemony”, in Min-hyung Kim and James Caporaso (eds.). Power Relations in Comparative Regionalism: Europe, East Asia and Latin America. Routledge: London and New York. Pp. 18-43.
Marcus Brunnermeier et al. “German-French Differences in Economic Philosophies”, in The Euro and the Battle of Ideas. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 56-82.
Week #5 In-person seminar (Tomasz Woźniakowski)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
Which cause of the financial crisis is most convincing? Why?
Week 6 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
NO TEACHING, BANK HOLIDAY ON 1ST NOVEMBER
Week #6 The overall political context that prevails in the four countries selected for the analysis, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Please note that the below chapters are all part of the core textbook
Christopher J. Carmen & Kathleen Volk Miller, United Kingdom, “1.1 The Context of British Politics”, pp. 3-21.
William Safran & Michelle Hale Williams, France, “2.1 The Context of French Politics”, pp. 99-111.
David Conradt, Germany, “3.1 The Context of German Politics”, pp. 217-241.
Raffaella Nanetti and Robert Leonardi, Italy, “4.1 The Context of Italian Politics”, pp. 317-337.
Week #6 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
What are the defining characteristics of each political system that we will be studying?
Does history matter?
What are the differences between the politics of the 1920s and 1930s vis-a-vis the post WWII period?
Does national sovereignty matter?
Week 7 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #7 Where is the Power? The political institutions, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Robert Leonardi)
Week #7 Where is the Power? The political institutions, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Christopher J. Carmen & Kathleen Volk Miller, United Kingdom. “1.2 Where is the Power?” pp. 22-48.
William Safran & Michelle Hale Williams, France, “2.2 Where is the Power?”, pp. 113-141.
David Conradt, Germany, “3.2 Where is the Power?”, pp.242-258.
Raffaella Nanetti and Robert Leonardi, Italy, “4.2 Where is the Power?”, pp. 338-358.
Week #7 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
How is democratic control exercised?
How effective is executive power?
What limitations are there on the use of power?
Week 8 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #8 How is power used? Policy making and policy outputs, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Robert Leonardi)
Week #8 How is power used? Policy making and policy outputs, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Christopher J. Carmen & Kathleen Volk Miller, United Kingdom. “1.4 Who is power used?”, pp. 72-86.
William Safran & Michelle Hale Williams, France, “2.4 Who is power used?”, pp. 185-195.
David Conradt, Germany, “3.4 Who is power used?”, pp. 287-301.
Raffaella Nanetti and Robert Leonardi, Italy, “4.4 Who is power used?”, pp. 414-434.
Week #8 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
How is power used?
Week 9 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #9 The future of national political developments, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Robert Leonardi)
Week #9 The future of national political developments, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Christopher J. Carmen & Kathleen Volk Miller, United Kingdom. “1.5 What is the future of British politics?”, pp. 87-96.
William Safran & Michelle Hale Williams, France, “2.5 What is the future of French politics?”, pp. 196-214.
David Conradt, Germany, ““3.5 What is the future of German politics?”, pp. 302-314.
Raffaella Nanetti and Robert Leonardi, Italy, ““4.5 What is the future of Italian politics?”, pp. 435-450.
Week #9 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
United Kingdom: The impact of Brexit.
Italy: Italian politics after Draghi and the new Parliament
France: Cohabitation between center and left.
Germany: German politics without Russia. Have the post-war restraints on German national politics been taken away? Is the future the past?
Week 10 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Week #10 The European Union: Federal state or international organization?, online lecture 18.00 – 18.45 (Robert Leonardi)
Donald Hancock, European Union, “All five chapters 8.1 – 8.5” pp. 639-718
Week #10 Summary session, in-person lecture 12.15 – 13.30 (Robert Leonardi)
Week #10 In-person seminar (Robert Leonardi)
Group A 9.00 – 10.00
Group B 10.15 – 11.15
Is the European Union a “state” or an international organization?
What does the future hold: enlargement, deepening or dissolution?
What has been the impact of the Ukraine war?
Week 11 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Please note that this course has only 10 weeks of teaching due to starting w/c 26th September. Students will be compensated for the delayed start.
Week 12 Contenuto sessioni on line e on campus
Please note that this course has only 10 weeks of teaching due to starting w/c 26th September. Students will be compensated for the delayed start.