Instructional goals
The course will provide an opportunity for better understanding how economic theories have dealt with major economic issues, especially growth and development, technology and innovation, unemployment and the role of the state in the economy. The main purpose is to acquaint the student with a comparative approach to a wide, although inevitably selected, set of major theories in the history of economic thought. The period considered covers almost two centuries, but with a more specific focus on the last one hundred years, in the attempt to show that economics has underwent a process of significant change before becoming what it is today. In this process of change, economics acquired new perspectives and methods of investigation, but also lost useful insights and approaches. In order to highlight this concept, the course will make frequent comparisons between current mainstream economics, itself subject to a process of change and criticism, and past theories.
The course will follow a chronological order, beginning with the French and English authors of the 18th century who, at the same time as capitalism was spreading, tried to understand the main features and long-term trends of the market economy. Turgot, Smith and Ricardo fought for Free Trade, against the protectionist views of the Ancien Régime. We will then move to Marx and the issue of power relations in the economy and Mill’s political economy and philosophical radicalism. The economics of Marshall and Walras will provide the subject for a comparison between general and partial equilibrium theories and their methodological underpinnings at the beginning of the marginal revolution. The part of the course on Schumpeter will present a conceptualization of the dynamic of capitalism, innovation, growth and entrepreneurship that had a long-lasting influence on economics. The final part will focus on Keynes who did not believe in the self-adjusting properties of the economy. His approach to economics is based on the awareness that most crucial decisions in economics are made under uncertainty. In contrast to Keynes, we will also examine different views of liberism, including Hayek, the Austrian School and the ordoliberalism that shaped the constitution of the European Monetary Union .
Prerequisites
Basic knowledge of micro and macroeconomics.
Intended learning outcomes
Knowledge and understanding:
The course will offer a comparative approach to the history of economic thought, showing that economics as it exists today is a relatively recent acquisition. Covering almost two centuries, but with a focus on the last one hundred years, the course will enable the students to compare different economic theories, both from the point of view of their inner logic and explanatory power as well as for their applications to policy.
Applying knowledge and understanding
Students will be able to:
i) contextualize economic theories, examining the relationship that exists between the emergence of a new theory or paradigm and the economic issues of the time and place in which the new approach is developed
ii) compare economic theories, viewed as alternative explanations of economic phenomena as well as intellectual toolkits that can shape economic choices
Making judgements:
In the examination and comparison of different theories, students are expected to judge their logical coherence and evaluate the empirical conditions that make for their application to individual or social choice. They are also encouraged to evaluate how different approaches to economic analysis give more emphasis to certain economic phenomena (e.g. growth, distribution, business cycle, etc.) while implicitly treating other phenomena as less relevant.
Communications skills
As the language and concepts of economics evolved through history, students are expected to be able to explain each theory in its own terms, to convey the meaning of a new concept when it is introduced and to explain how the same concept evolved through history.
Learning skills
We expect students to acquire a new and more critical perspective on economics, based on the idea that economics as it exists today is not just the outcome of a cumulative scientific process but also the result of choices that were made as to what is relevant and what is not from the point of view of professional economists.
Course Contents
1. Introduction; 2. Classical political economy 3. Marx 4. From Classical political economy to the Marginalist Revolution 5. Walras and Pareto on general equilibrium theory and the role of psychology in economics 6. Marshall’s partial equilibrium theory and industrial analysis 7. Schumpeter on entrepreneurship, economic development and the future of capitalism 8. Keynes’s theory of employment, interest and money 9. Macroeconomics after Keynes. 10. Liberism in the 20th century 11. Current trends in economic thought
Reference Books
Roncaglia, Alessandro. A Brief History of Economic Thought, Cambridge University Press, 2017
Medema, Steven G. and Warren J. Samuels. The History of Economic Thought: A Reader. Second ed. New York;London;: Routledge, 2013, selected chapters
Hayek, F. A. 'The use of Knowledge in Society.' The American Economic Review 35, no. 4 (1945): 519-530.
The slides with the course lectures are available on the Luiss Learn platform.
Any additional readings will be indicated and made available during the course.
Teaching Methods
Each lesson consists of a presentation of the topic that will be discussed with the class - active student participation is required. In some cases, students will be required to read in advance items in the reading list.
Assessment Method
Compulsory written examination.
For those who only take the final written examination, the evaluation method consists of the final examination (written examination (compulsory), 90%) + an evaluation of participation in the course (10%).
Students may also choose to take an intermediate (non-compulsory) written test on the first part of the programme. In this case, the assessment method consists of an intermediate test (written test only, 45%) and a final test (written test (compulsory), 45%) + an assessment of participation in the course (10%).
The mid-term test and the final examination consist of open questions (i.e. the questions are not multiple-choice)
The following assessment criteria will be taken into account when awarding the final grade in thirtieths: knowledge and understanding of the course content (60% of the final grade); ability to independently apply the comparative approach used during the course (30% of the final grade); active participation in the lessons (10% of the final grade).
Thesis assignment criteria
A minimum grade of 27
Week 1
1. Introduction. When and how economics became a science? And what kind of science?
French économistes and British Classical Political Economists: where does the wealth of nations come from? And which is the best way to preserve it?
2. Adam Smith. Moral sympathy vs. self-interest: is there an ‘Adam Smith Problem’? The harmony between individual self-interest and social interest: the invisible hand
3. The Wealth of Nations. Division of labour and productivity, value theory.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 2 §2.6, ch. 4 §4.6, ch.5, §§1-8
A. Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (extracts), in S.G. Medema and W.J. Samuels, The History of Economic Thought: A Reader
Week 2
4. Ricardo. Ricardo on Free Trade. Ricardo’s theory of distribution.
5. Ricardo’s theory of value and distribution. Premises: Malthus on population, Say’s law of markets. The theory: labour theory of value; the determination of wages, rent and profits.
6. Ricardo and the third edition of the Principles. Ricardo and Babbage on machinery.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch.6, §§ 1-3 (Malthus, Say’s Law); ch.7 ( §§ 5 and 6 excluded) (Ricardo); ch.8, §§ 7 (Babbage)
Week 3
7. Marx’s critique of capitalism. Value theory and the theory of exploitation.
8. Crisis and technological progress.
9. The laws of movement of capitalism.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 9, §§1-6
Week 4
10. Bentham’s utilitarianism.
11. Mill’ political economy and philosophical radicalism.
12. The “marginalist revolution”.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, Ch. 6, § 7 (Bentham); Ch 8, §§ 8-9 (Mill); Ch 10 §§ 1-5 (Marginalist revolution)
S.G. Medema and W.J. Samuels, The History of Economic Thought: A Reader (extracts)
Week 5
13. Walras and general equilibrium: how independent decisions of individual agents generate harmony and not chaos.
14. Jevons and experimental psychology. Jevons and the limits to growth (the “coal question”)
15. Marshall’s ‘partial equilibrium analysis’ and‘short casual chains’. Time period analysis.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 12, §§1-2 (Walras), ch. 10, §§3-5 (Jevons), ch. 13, §§1-5 (Marshall)
Week 6
16. Marshall’s theory of the firm and industrial analysis.
17. Marshall on competition and increasing returns, the life cycle hypothesis, the representative firm, internal and external economies, the role of the entrepreneur.
18. Sraffa’s criticism of Marshallian theory; the theory of imperfect and monopolistic competition.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 13, §§ 1-5 (Marshall); ch. 16, §3 (Sraffa)
A. Marshall, Principles of Economics (extracts), in S.G. Medema and W.J. Samuels, The History of Economic Thought: A Reader.
Week 7
19. Schumpeter, method and works. Statics and dynamics, disequilibrium and growth.
20. The entrepreneur and the banker in Schumpeter’s theory of economic development. Economic development and business cycles.
21. Fisher and Quantity theory of money.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History,ch. 15, §§1-4 (Schumpeter), ch. 12, §4 (Fisher),
Week 8
22. Keynes and his General Theory.
23. Liquidity preference and the role of money in Keynes’s theory. Short term expectations. The principle of effective demand.
24. Keynes’s theory of rational behaviour under uncertainty: the Treatise on Probability.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 14, §§ 1-5
Week 9
24. A restatement of Keynes’s theory. Economic policies for full employment.
25. Keynes’s on the state of long term expectations: speculation, long term investment and the functioning of the stock market.
26. Keynes’s social philosophy and the role of the state. Liquidity preference at international level: Keynes’s plan for Bretton Woods.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, The Wealth of Ideas, ch. 14, §§ 1-5
Week 10
27. Pareto and further developments of general equilibrium.
28. Pareto and the axiomatization of economics.
28. Pareto’s attempts at separating psychology and economics. The theory of rational choice.
A. Roncaglia, Brief History,ch. 12, §3 (Pareto)
Week 11
29. Macroeconomics after Keynes: the IS-LM model and the neoclassical synthesis
30. The Phillips Curve.
29. Milton Friedman on the ‘The role of monetary policy’.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, Brief History, ch. 17
Week 12
33. Old and new liberism : the Austrian School and Hayek
34. Ordoliberalism and the European Monetary Union.
35. Current trends in economic thought
36. Summary and conclusion.
Reference reading material:
A. Roncaglia, The Age of Fragmentation, Cambridge University Press (2019), ch. 4 §§5-7 and ch. 8 §§ 1-3
F. Hayek, "The use of knowledge in Society" American Economic Review , 35 (1945), pp. 519-530