sustainable justice and ADR


sustainable justice and ADR

Marco Marinaro

Instructional goals

The aim of the course is: to explore the theme of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, especially with regard to civil and commercial mediation, in a perspective of complementarity and balance with jurisdiction oriented towards the research of an efficient and sustainable system of civil justice.

Intended learning outcomes

Knowledge and understanding: The student will acquire full knowledge of the general categories of ADR procedures and the more complex system of civil justice in a perspective of sustainability, also considering the framework of the European Union and of Italian constitutional principles. Applying knowledge and understanding: The student will be able to interpret and apply, even with respect to concrete cases, the principles and institutions of ADR. The presence of online content in the digital platform and the holding of practical workshops will allow you to verify in real time the skills acquired. The acquisition of such knowledge will also be verified through intermediate tests. At the end of the course there will be an oral exam. Making judgements: The student will be able to collect data and materials to analyze the normative sources and the relevant guidelines in doctrine and jurisprudence with reference to the discipline of ADR procedures and will acquire the ability to independently evaluate these data by formulating critical judgments on the application of rules and identifying appropriate solutions to specific, practical cases. Communication skills: The student will be able to master the technical-legal lexicon of ADR procedures. By participating in the different activities of the course (lessons, simulated procedures, laboratories, etc.) the student will learn to put into practice such communicative skills in different contexts, acquiring further argumentative skills. Learning skills: The technical-legal knowledge acquired during the course will allow the student to understand and interpret autonomously the latest normative, doctrinal and jurisprudential developments related to the regulation of ADR systems, being able to undertake post-lauream vocational training. No pre-requisite required. Interaction and social conflict. Introduction to dispute resolution systems. Types of ADR: negotiation, mediation, arbitration. Mediation in the European and Italian legal systems. General principles and the evolution of ADR in Italy. Collaborative law. ADR systems for consumers and businesses: the role of independent administrative authorities. Evolving profiles of civil justice: effectiveness, efficiency and sustainability.

Course Contents

Interaction and social conflict. Introduction to dispute resolution systems. Types of ADR: negotiation, mediation, arbitration. Mediation in the European and Italian legal systems. General principles and the evolution of ADR in Italy. Collaborative law. ADR systems for consumers and businesses: the role of independent administrative authorities. Evolving profiles of civil justice: effectiveness, efficiency and sustainability.

Reference Books

Troisi, C. (2024). Mediazione e giustizia complementare. Giappichelli. Optional readings (to be agreed with the teacher): Chase, O. G., & Ferrarese, M. R. (2009). Gestire i conflitti. Diritto, cultura, rituale. Laterza. Luiso, F.P. (2025). Diritto processuale civile, V, La risoluzione non giurisdizionale delle controversie. Giuffrè Francis Lefebvre. Marinaro, M. (2023 n. 3). La mediazione riformata e le relazioni d’impresa - Journal Le Società - Ipsoa (pp. 359-371). Marinaro, M. (2024 n. 1). Il nuovo regolamento ministeriale per la mediazione civile e commerciale: profili rilevanti del “primo incontro” – Journal Il Foro Italiano – La Tribuna (cc. 21-29). Marinaro, M. (edited by) (2025). Diritto della mediazione civile e commerciale. Gruppo24Ore.

Teaching Methods

Frontal lectures and open debates in the class are envisaged in the teaching course. Guests from the world of institutions, universities, businesses, professions. Critical discussion on selected topics, based on scientific articles. Use of new teaching learning methodologies like: inquiry-based learning; problem based learning; peer education; flipped classroom.

Assessment Method

The final grade will be determined by the assessment of active class participation (20%), group work (30%), and the final oral exam (50%). During the oral exam, the student will be required to show that he/she knows and understands notions and principles of ADR methods and that he/she is able to apply them to practical cases. The student is expected to be able to independently analyse sources and relevant theories of ADR systems and to use the appropriate technical and legal vocabulary, thus proving that he/she has acquired the study method and the learning ability for carrying on, also independently, further study of the matter. The following evaluation criteria will be considered to assign the final grade, expressed in thirtieths: - knowledge and understanding of the principles and notions of ADR methods and ability to apply them to concrete cases (70%); appropriate use of the technical and legal vocabulary, ability to analyze and evaluate relevant sources and acquisition of the study method (30%). Learning gaps concerning one or more notions or principles will lead to an insufficient evaluation, even in presence of a basic knowledge of the matter.

Thesis assignment criteria

Interest for the discipline. Active participation to the classes. Quality and relevance of the proposed topic.

Week 1

Session 1 Interaction and social conflict. Power, law, interests. Imposed order and negotiated order. Cultural models and conflict resolutions systems. Session 2 The birth and spread of ADR. Historical roots and evolutionary profiles. Heteronomy and autonomy in conflict resolution. From judgment to agreement. Competitive and collaborative strategies.

Week 2

Session 1 Crisis of legal modernity and crisis of the judicial system. Access to civil justice and access to jurisdiction. From the hypertrophy of jurisdiction to the minimum jurisdiction. Subsidiarity and ‘degiurisdizionalizzazione’. Subjective perception of conflict. From behavioral to cognitive sciences: Decision-making processes. Session 2 Access to civil justice: effective protection and non-judicial systems. The trial and alternative justice. Justice and mediation: structural perspective and function. The relationship between the economic system and civil justice: between efficiency and efficientism. The Italian “Manifesto” of Complementary Justice.

Week 3

Session 1 The International and European dimension: the main milestones. Green papers, recommendations, directives. The extreme poles of the dispute resolution systems: from negotiation to trial. ADR in legislative vocabulary. ADR systems taxonomy. Pre-conflict agreements: prevention and integrated assistance. DRB systems. Session 2 Historical-systematic overview of ADR procedures in the Italian legal system. Judicial and extrajudicial conciliation in the Code of Civil Procedure and in special legislation: introductory profiles. Regulated and ad-hoc systems. Conciliation models: facilitative and evaluative conciliation. Models of arbitration: legal nature and relationships. The solution of the civil dispute between trial and negotiation.

Week 4

Session 1 Civil and commercial mediation: from Directive 52/2008 to Legislative Decree no. 28/2010. Session 2 The Italian normative framework of mediation. The deflatory equation and social pacification. From the Delegated Act ex art. 60 L. 69/2009 to Legislative Decree no. 28/2010. The 2013 reform. The Cartabia Reform: from the Delegated Act n. 206/2021 to Legislative Decree no. 149/2022 (and Legislative Decree no. 216/2024). Civil mediation: protection of rights and composition of interests.

Week 5

Session 1 The Italian model of civil mediation. Mandatory and optional mediation. Mediation delegated by the judge. The mediation clause. Session 2 Case law guidelines: cases and issues.

Week 6

Session 1 The mediation procedure ex Legislative Decree no. 28/2010; the ministerial implementing regulation (D.M. 150/2023) and the practices. Sessione 2 The role of the mediator: obligations and responsibility. The Rules of Procedure and procedural documents: from application to agreement.

Week 7

Session 1 Mediation for communal disputes. The Gelli-Bianco law for disputes concerning medical and medical responsibility. Session 2 The mediation in matter of consumption. Paritetic negotiations. Other ADR procedures for consumers. The ODR systems. The “amicable” agreement: Civil-law profiles.

Week 8

Session 1 Collaborative practice: method, ethics, procedure. Session 2 Negotiation as a means of settling civil disputes. Negotiation by lawyers (before trial): reconstructive profiles. Negotiation by lawyers in matters of separation and divorce.

Week 9

Session 1 ADR and public administration. ADR systems of independent administrative authorities. Session 2 AGCOM and ARERA conciliation.

Week 10

Session 1 Non-binding arbitration systems: the ABF model. Comparative profiles. Session 2 The Banking and Financial Ombudsman: an ADR model between private autonomy and banking supervision. The ABF procedure.

Week 11

Session 1 The Securities and Financial Ombudsman. The Insurance Ombudsman. Session 2 The role of the ICC (International Chamber of Commerce) of Paris in international arbitration and other ADR proceedings: ICC Regulations (Rules of Arbitration,Rules of ICC as Appointing Authority, Mediation Rules, Dispute Board Rules, Expert Rules, and DOCDEX Rules); Model Clauses. The role of the Arbitration Chamber of Milan.

Week 12

Session 1 ADR systems for the protection of intellectual property: the WIPO model. Session 2 Settlement of civil disputes and effective protection of rights. Sustainable justice: reconstructive and systematic profiles. Evolutionary and reform perspectives.